Faith
and the Arts:
A Religion Teacher's Reflections, Ideas and Practices
9/5/12
I've been enjoying doing the section on wonder and mystery
at Junior Cycle. It's challenging to do this with 2nd year students, but
I find arts resources helpful - for the first time I got to use a clip
from The Way, the film starring Martin Sheen as a father doing
the Camino de Satiago pilgrimage for his deceased son, played by Emilio
Estevez, Sheen's real life son and the director of the film. Overall the
film is problematic for school use because of the casual use of soft drugs,
but there are some great set pieces. For these classes I used the scene
where the pilgrims finally arrive at the Cathedral - it's a wonderful
and moving scene. I alsp played the song "What a Wonderful World".
I used the versionby Eva Cassidy from her Wonderful World album
(also on the DVD Eva Cassidy Sings - see clip on left),
though there's always the definitive version by Louis Armstrong, while
Anne Murray has a decent verson on her album of inspirational songs What
a Wonderful World, and I like the version by L'Angelus on their album
Live Cuts.
27/4/12
Last night I hosted a concert in Arklow with Sarah McQuaid. And
what an impressive singer-songwriter! Some of her material has spiritual
resonance - two I like in particular: a lovely song of thankfulness, "In
Gratitude I Sing", and a touching reflection on those who have gone
before us "In Derby Cathedral". Listen to them here below. Both
songs are from her new album The Plum Tree and the Rose.
25/4/12
Last Sunday night Would You Believe (RTE 1) ended its current season
with the appealing story of TeenspiriT, an initiative to bring
young people closer to their Catholic faith through music. A major success
in Kerry for the last few years, the organisers now seek to bring the
spirit to Dublin. The programme followed their enthusiastic efforts to
get ready for this Sunday night's live show in the Olympia. The Kerry
team were finding it hard to impact with the faith message, but they were
certainly generating an infectious enthusiasm for the music, an experience
they hope will bear fruit in the future. The programme can be seen here
on the RTE Player until Sunday 13th May. Read more about TeenspiriT here.
In the last few days I've been discussing prayer with junior
classes. As part of it I decided to do a little prayer in the classroom
- just lighting a candle, doing some prayer readings and playing some
music. One song I found useful was "Where Do I Go?" by Ashley
Cleveland and Gary Chapman, from that great album Songs From the Loft
(play it on left) . This is a catchy song that's actually about
prayer and fitted in nicely with what we had been doing in class. Some
of the students were actually joining in. I think it would also make a
great song for a school choir or folk group.
18/4/12 Last
Sunday night I was delighted to hear a talk by Sr Rose Pacatte
from USA. in the Blessed Sacrament Chapel Hall on Bachelor's Walk in Dublin.
Sr Rose has written several books on film and faith, and is a prolific
blogger on film and other media matters. Check out Sr
Rose Pacatte's Movie Blog for plenty of information and ideas. Also
check her more general site here.
Sr Rose advised "deep viewing" of films, and at home in the
States practised what she called "Cinema Divina" with small
groups - using the movies for spiritual insight and linking them to Scripture.
I was delighted
on Moday to give a workshop on Film and Music in R.E. at the Annual
Conference of the Post Primary Diocesan Advisors in All Hallows, Drumcondra,
Dublin. I showed clips from many of the films mentioned on this website,
on the blog and film
pages (incl Of Gods and Men, Sophie Scholl, Nacho Libre, The Way, Amazing
Grace and the confession scene from Gran Torino - my first
chance to give this an outing!). I also suggested various ways of accessing
useful film clips (e.g. through Wingclips)
and how to make one's own clips using the recording function of VLC
Media Player. On the music front I played some clips from music DVDs
and CDs and recommended the albums I find most useful in RE - e.g. Songs
From the Loft and Coram Deo (Various Artists), Signatures
by John Michael Talbot, Another World by Liam Lawton. I also used,
for the first time, Mirrorscript teleprompter software - (Download
from here).
This is great for scrolling song lyrics - basically you load a plain text
file (e.g. from Notepad) into it and scroll it at whatever speed you choose.
To illustrate this I had great fun playing my ukulele and leading the
assembled Advisors in a rendition of Kumbya!
11/4/11 One
of my favourites programmes over Easter was the Preston Passion
(BBC 1 Good Friday) - a live pageant from the streets of Preston in Northern
England. It was notable for the way the Crown of Thorns motif and images
suggesting the Crucifixion were interwoven with the action, which included
three pre-recorded dramas linking the Easter story with the experience
of Preston itself. An aerial view showed the Crown of Thorns suggested
by strategically placed red ribbons and flags, and I noticed the same
motif on the choir members.
One of the dramas linked the story of Jesus to that of a social reformer
from Preston who fell foul of the political and religious authorities
of the time - the town's Mayor filled in nicely for Pilate, right down
to the washing of hands; another took up the theme of Mary's sense of
loss at the death of Jesus to tell a touching story about Preston mothers
dreading the news of the death of their sons in the trenches of World
War 1; the third was a clever reworking of the Stations of the Cross (the
Station numbers are subtly embedded in the visuals) as a young girl with
an alcoholic mother made sacrifices for others and journeyed through her
own Via Dolorosa. All in all it was an imaginative reflection on the Good
Friday story, faithful to the original story, but finding much resonance
for today. I can see myself using clips from this programme in RE class
- e.g. looking at religious drama as an issue in itself, looking at the
Easter story in general, looking at how that story still has something
to say to us today. The short dramas are the perfect length for class
work, though the story of the young girl might be painful for some students
who might be in similar situations. There are several clips from the programme
here.
Last
night I finally got to see the film Gran Torino, where Clint Eastwood
plays an irascible old racist in conflict with local immigrants. There's
quite a bit of foul and racist language so I can't see myself using it
in school, but there's a interesting young priest in the story. He promised
the Eastwood character's wife who has just died that will keep an eye
on Walt and try to get him to Confession. Needless to say Grumpy old Walt
resists. The priest is young, and perhaps naieve (Walt didn't have much
time for his funeral oration) but he does persist and both of them learn
a lot about life and death. The scenes between them are quite entertaining
and thought provoking. Ultimately there's a touching and funny Confession
scene - another worthy addition to my collection of Confession scenes!
2/4/12
How sweet is to be on holidays! To finish up last term I gave some short
tests to the junior classes. As we had been doing "Images
of God" I used the Powerpoint (still available on request) as part
of the test - showing five images on scren and asking students to write
brief coments on each - it worked well. In this age of differentiation
I think it's important to give students something visual to work on for
each text. I also get them to draw in each test - again it caters for
the less academic, and makes for some very intersting images to assess.
This time I got students in 2nd Year to draw any scene from Last Supper
to Resurrection - the Last Supper was very popular, though I got some
lovely illustrations of the Resurrection. Might get the students' permission
to include them here after Easter. First Years had to do a poster/illustration
encouraging or showing the value of religious music as an element of worship.
I haven't marked them yet.
22/3/12
Still doing "Images of God" with 2nd Year students -
looking at images of God on film in particular this week, and still using
the old reliables - from the old Insight videos Martin Sheen as a young
God in The Walls Came Tumbling Down, Bob Newhart as a rather inoffensive
God in Packy, God as Trinity in Jesus B.C, Charlton Heston
as a rather gruff God in the film Almost an Angel, Morgan Freemnan
as God in Bruce Almighty or Evan Almighty (the most familiar portrayal
for students). I have issues with some elements of Bruce Almighty,
but that scene where he meets God for the first time is a howl. I
show the clips, get the students writing about them and then discussing
them.
I got a full class out of Old Testament images of God - and after looking
at some of the images, especially in the Psalms, I get the students to
draw any one image of their choosing.
That Powerpoint I've done up with various images of God is still available
on request - use contact details over on left.
16/3/12
Went to see the Emmanuel2012 concert last Wednesday
night in the Helix and what a treat! 700 young people singing religious
songs with gusto - and over 2000 when you add the three nights together.
My own school was well represented, and two of our students got solos.
And there certainly were some strong solos this year. The backing musicians
were excellent as always - I was particularly impressed by the piano,
guitar and sax playing. One of the highlights of the night was the group
from St Mary's School for the Deaf who signed their way through all the
material - their persentation was beautuiful, graceful and inspiring.
(see clip above for a news item)
The material was introduced as "quality liturgical music" and
it was certainly that and more. A lot of the songs had Eucharist as a
theme, deliberately so I presume with the International Eucharistic Congress
coming up in June. The Congress theme song, "Though We Are Many"
by Bernard Sexton really felt like an anthem on the night. There were
a few pieces from Liam Lawton's Glendalough Mass, along with "Take
and Eat, This is My Body", by Ian Callanan, who was conductor
for the night. I also liked his re-working of the old hymn "O Sacrament
Most Holy". "Were Not Our Hearts", also by Callanan, is
a fine song about the disciples on the road to Emmaus. There were some
crowd pleasing foot stompers like "Trading My Sorrows" and "Over
My Head", but the final "Amen" really lifted the roof.
Have been
working on Images of God with second year students, always an enjoyable
module. First off I get them to make their best effort to draw God. Then
I ramble around the class discussing the various illustrations, e.g. asking
why so many concentrate (sometimes to excess!) on giving God hair. This
year as usual a minority drew abstract shapes or an eye in the sky, while
most drew human forms, mostly older versions of Jesus (why so much emphasis
on beards??). As usual there was one or two that left the page blank,
which I complemented, even if the motivation was more laziness than theology.
One noteworthy quote: astudent looked at another's drawing of God and
said: "If He looks like that God help him!" At the end of the process
I noted on the board which aspects of God the students were trying to
convey in their pictures. In the following class I used a Powerpoint I
had put together with various images of God from art and film. This is
available on request - use contact link over on left side panel.
10/3/12
Have just come across an interesting article on praying the Rosary
through art. Professor Maria Stella Ceplecha from St Paul, Miinnesota
has chosen the Joyful mysteries to illustrate her point and has illustrated
her article with classic paintings. The article can be accessed by clicking
here.
9/3/12
During the week I continued the classes on the the days in Jesus' life
leading up to Easter. Getting some great artwork from the students, with
lots of discussion points, even if they can only manage "stick men"
versions! The scenes from Jesus of Nazareth can still pack an emotional
punch, even after seeing them so many times over the years. Getting songs
to go with each phase has been more challenging. For the trial scene best
I could think of was "Who Hit You Then" by Sal Solo from his
great album Look at Christ, which is hard to find in any format
(I'm still using my cassette). There are many fine songs about the crucifixion
- I used "Were You There", sung by Russ Taffe and Selah, from
the album Press On. For the Resurrection I used "Christ the
Lord is Risen Today" by Ashley Cleveland, and "He is Risen"
by John Michael Talbot. I've included a few of the songs below.
1/3/12
With my 2nd Years I've been doing the sequence of events from the Last
Supper to the Resurrection. I like to combine the relevant Scripture
reading, a video clip from one of the lives of Jesus on film - I still
tend to stick with Jesus of Nazareth for this sequence. Then I get the
students to draw their own version of the event in question. This gives
me a chance to ramble around the classroom having discussions with individuals
or groups of students. This time around I've tried to find relevant songs
to play in the classroom while students are drawing. So far I've used
"Come to the Table" by Michael Card for The Last Supper and
his song "Why" for the Garden of Gethsemane scene, both from
his album trilogy The Life. Play clips below. Come To The Table by Michael
Card on Grooveshark Why (Card) by Michael
Card on Grooveshark
23/2/12 I
came across an interesting article today about a film star who became
a nun and is now the subject of a documentary nominated for an Academy
Award this year. Check out the story on the Catholic
Ireland website. Apart from this there is much of interest to RE teachers
on catholicireland.net
and its sister website Catholic
News Ireland.
Another website
very useful to RE treachers is Busted
Halo. In particular check out the "Entertainment and Lifestyle"
and "Video" sections. There are some snappy videos and useful
film reviews among other resources.
I've been watching some music programmes, two in particular,
that reflect different approaches to the world. The Voice of Ireland
(RTE 1, Sunday nights) could become addictive if you get drawn into
the lives of these real people. The best thing about it is the quality
of the singers, and there's no denying that. But there's a lot I don't
like about it - the gimmick of having the judges initially sitting with
their backs to the performers was awkward I thought, and quite honestly
I often find the approach of the judges irritating. There's the in-built
disappointment-as-entertainment - such shows are not a success, it seems,
unless there are public tears. It's not the Coliseum, but it feeds the
same unpleasant desires some people have to see others brought down. And
as for the last two weeks - having excellent singers singing duets where
only one of them goes through is a terrible idea. The superb Scottish
folk singer Eddi Reader turned up on the show as a voice coach, which
surprised me, because she was much more at home on The Transatlantic
Sessions, currently in its fifth season, Friday nights on RTE 1 and
BBC 4. Now this is a music show you could really enthuse about - top-notch
folk, blues, country and traditional musicians and singers sitting around
a house in Scotland playing and singing their hearts out and obviously
loving every minute of it. This a world full of creativity and genuine
spirit, free of gimmickry and narrow competitiveness. They don't often
include a gospel song, but last Friday night's episode on RTE 1 (you can
catch it this Friday night on BBC 4) ended with a mighty gospel song,
"Jesus" sung by Amos Lee (see clip above - replacing previous clip 1/3/12)
with an all-star backing group including Donal Lunny and Declan O'Rourke,
writer of "Galileo". I can see myself using this song in my TY Religion
classes at a leter stage - the whole fifth series is now available on
DVD.
Eddi Reader made a third appearance, busy woman, on the John Murray
Show (RTE Radio 1) on Wednesday of last week. Apart from singing some
fine songs in studio she spoke of her reluctance to be on that Voice
of Ireland show. She was disgusted by the typical TV talent shows
like the X-Factor and didn't like the idea of sitting in judgement
on the talent of others. She was finally persuaded to try it by Brian
Kennedy - the crucial factor for her was that all those involved were
themselves musicians. Eventually she felt so bad about one contestant
losing that she gave him a slot
singing with her on stage. I think she should stick with the genuine and
avoid the razzmatazz!
11/2/12 Got to experience a bit of Heaven last Tuesday night at the National
Concert Hall - event was the Transatlantic Sessions, featuring
some superb folk musicians and singers, a veritable folk orchestra playing
great instrumentals and accompanying great singers like Eddi Reader, Raul
Malo (of the Mavericks), Karen Matheson and Paul Brady who turned by surprise
for the encore, a mighty version of "Hey Good Lookin'". The
only religious interest was the spiritual imagery in the song "Galileo"
sung on the night by singer-songwriter Declan O'Rourke who really impressed.
The TV show of the same name started last night on RTE at 7.30 and wlill
run for the next few weeks. If you missed it you catch it on BBC 4 where
the new season starts next Friday Fri 17th February at 8.30 pm.
Songs
of Praise has to be one of the longest-running religious TV shows.
Still going strong on BBC 1, Sunday afternoons, the episode on Sunday
of last week featured Progressive Rock legend Rick Wakeman, who has played
keyboards with the likes of David Bowie and his own group "Yes". I was
surprised to learn that it was Wakeman who played the distinctive piano
part on Cat Steven's hit "Morning Has Broken", which he recreated
on the programme with Laura Wright doing the singing honours. Wakeman's
background was Baptist, and despite the rock lifestyle he always prayed,
but felt a particular clear signal from God at one stage to evaluate his
life direction and get it into shape. Prog rock or not his choice of hymns
was very traditional, with songs like "Amazing Grace" and "All
People That on Earth do Dwell" - accompanied by the hearty singing
of the assembled congregation and his own piano licks, sometimes complementary,
sometimes a little over-ornate. One standout was the spiritual instrumental
"Gone But Not Forgotten", written earlier but which accompanied
him on the death of his mother. I could see myself using some of songs
and some of the interview clips in class, especially in my TY module on
faith and music. One of the issues that I raise in those classes is the
question of how an instrumental can be spiritual. That produces quite
a divergence of views among the students - some reject the idea, but one
responded a while back with a spiritual instrumental of his own!
2/2/12 Last
week I got to see the Secret Sisters live at the Sugar Club in
Leeson St, Dublin - first time there and what a great venue! I've been
playing their album frequently since Christmas and have been impressed
by the sweet country harmony singing. They sound a little like the Everly
Brothers, a suggestion they commented on at the gig. There's one gospel
song on the album - House of Gold (see it here),
an old Hank Williams song, and on the night they sang a beautiful version
of In the Sweet Bye and Bye (see it here),
and their own River Jordan - (see it here).
Can't see myself using any of these in class as my students are not exactly
country music fans, but I find it uplifting and refreshing for myself,
great aesthetic and spiritual nourishment. So there!
In Second Year classes I've been looking at the Beatitudes
as part of a study of Discipleship and the Kingdom of God. Has fitted
in nicely with Catholic Schools Week as well. Have been collecting
resources on the Beatitudes for years, and have used some prayers from
David Konstant's prayer book on the Beatitudes and the Rosary as part
of prayer services for the week that's in it. A contemporay album devoted
to the Beatitudes would be a great idea, and I'm surprised that someone
like Liam Lawton, John Michael Talbot or Michael Card hasn't tried it.
For the moment I've used songs like The Beatitudes by the Monks
of Glenstal Abbey (clip on left) from their album "Biscantoret",
Behold Now the Kingdom by John Michael Talbot, The Cloud's Veil
by Liam Lawton - good for "Blesed are those who mourn" I think
- and for the same Beatitude Now is the Time for Tears, by Charlie
Peacock from the "Coram Deo" album. I hope at some stage to
develop a special page for Beatitudes resources.
21/1/12 Eternal Law is an intriguing new English drama from ITV on Thursday
nights. If you suspend your critical and theological faculties it can
be quite enjoyable. Keep in mind that my comments are based on the first
two episodes only. The plot features two angels come to earth as lawyers
to help people out. They clash with a fallen angel, a very sinister prosecution
lawyer who is often surrounded by flames and pushes beggars into the river.
One of the angels is new to the earth and moves from initial fascination
to being baffled at the puzzling way people carry on. The other angel
has been to earth before but blotted his angelic copybook by falling in
love - he meets up again with this woman who doesn't recognise him from
before and he has to resist the temptation to fall again. Irish actor
Orla Brady does a fine job as "Mrs Sheringham" an angel who became mortal
for love but who helps out those angels currently on assignment from the
unseen God figure Mr Mountjoy. If you can ignore a little crude language
and dodgy theology it's entertaining fare for mature viewers, thought
provoking, amusing, compassionate, philosophical and, in last week's episode
about a child custody case, quite moving.
10/1/12 One
of the best films I saw during the holidays was Doubt , starring
Meryl Streep as a school principal and nun who must deal with the suspicion
that the school chaplain, played by Philip Seymour Hoffman is conducting
an inappropriate relationship with a student. It is set in the early 1960's
and the period flavour is well conveyed. The acting is excellent as would
be expected of Streep and Hoffman, and the script by John Patrick Shanley
has a sharpness and intelligence that is rare in mainstream cinema. The
controversial issue of abuse is handled subtly and with restraint, and
I didn't sense any hidden agendas or axe-grinding. One could raise issues
- e.g. why does no-one seem to question the child? Is the mother's attitude
credible? Yet in the context of the time and within the world of the film
it was believable. As regards school use, I'd be hesitant. There is a
useful scene where the priest gives a strong sermon on the damaging effects
of gossip, but I think the film is best suited to a mature audience. For
very young students it might just
reinforce the paedophile priest stereotype, and they mightn't get the
film's subtleties.
9/1/12
Back to school today. I hate letting go of Christmas and all the great
music, so I drag it out by covering the Three Wise Men in some
Junior classes. After all, if it wasn't for them we'd probably be back
in school earlier in January, and maybe we'd have received no Christmas
gifts!. This year I'm doing it mainly with 1st Years as the others have
experienced my resources in the past. As usual I've used the song "We
Three Kings" and shown the arrival of the Wise Men from the film
The Nativity Story, and also from the modern musical version The
Liverpool Nativity. Some video clips, and the music I use can be found
on the Advent and Christmas Resources page.
I brought in my crib from home with the wise men figurines and added it
to the sacred space table.
3/1/12 I caught Carole King and Friends at Christmas on BBC 4
on Christmas night, which mainly featured the secular music of the season.
King herself, 70 years old next month and still going strong, impressed
with standards like "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" and new song
"New Year's Day", but there was a mellow version of "Silent Night" from
Richard Hawley (clip on left has him singing this version on another occasion).
Her own songs were from her new album "A Christmas Carole", which was
released in USA as "A Holiday Carole" - different strokes for different
markets! There was no such hedging on the Johnny Cash Christmas Special
from 1970, shown on BBC 4 a few times in the last week or two - he clearly
spoke about the Christian message in Christmas, no political correctness
from the great man! Some might have found his spoken interludes a bit
preachy, but could you complain when the fireside music session featured
Cash, the Everly Brothers , Roy Orbison, the Carter Family and more?
2/1/12
Canadian singer Neil Young was the star of a great music documentary/concert
film Heart of Gold
shown on TG 4 Tues 27 December, and the heart of that film was two concert
segments - one that featured his old songs like "Four Strong Winds" (by
Ian and Sylvia Tyson) and one that showcased more recent material, including
"When God Made Me" a rather ambiguous reflection on God's relationship
with people: "Did he give me the gift of voice/so some could silence me?/Did
he give me the gift of vision/not knowing what I might see?/Did he give
me the gift of compassion/to help my fellow man? When God made me." The
sound of someone searching, with lots of questions, but sometimes it seems
our age is afraid of answers.
30/12/11
Got to hear lots of Christmas music over the holidays. One new song that
impressed was "St Christopher", by the Lost Brothers,
performed on The John Murray Show on Wed 21 Dec. Fortunately the video
cameras were rolling.
6/12/11 Got
another new Christmas CD. A
Christmas Carole is a cleverly titled album from singer-songwriter
Carole King ("You've Got a Friend" among others), just released.
For the most part these are secular standards like "Carol of the
Bells" "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" and "Sleigh
Ride", and they're sung well. There's also the traditional Jewish
"Chanukah Prayer", and the more Christian "Do You Hear
What I Hear". "My Favourite Things" was an unusual addition,
though there are some Christmas references ("Doorbells and sleigh
bells and schnitzel with noodles"!). All in all it's a pleasant work
but I'd like it to have been more adventurous, with some more original
songs - the nearest we get is "Christmas Paradise" and "New
Year's Day", both co-written by King's daughter Louise Goffin. You
can hear track samples and watch a related video at Amazon.
1/12/11
It's that time of year again, time to whip out the Advent and Christmas
music. I love it! My article suggesting resources for the season is
here and this year I've added a playlist of
Advent songs that I think would go down well. I did Advent services with
junior classes during the week and used mainly O Come O Come Emmanuel
by Kim Hill from her "Real Christmas" album (the can be heard
on the playlist) and John Angotti's Prepare Ye the Way from his
Christmas album.
So far I've got no new Christmas albums this year (any ideas?),
but I did come across the EP "Christmas Sky" by a Californian
Singer J Peter Boles. I hadn't heard of him before, but I was impressed
- he remonds me of Tom Paxton. There are fine roots/acoustic versions,
with tasty guitar and mandolin, of God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen, Silent
Night, Go Tell It on the Mountain and Dona Nobis Pacem, along
with one new song Warm Winter's Eve in December which tells the
nativity story from the innkeeper's perspective - see clip above left.
On his website
you can hear samples of the tracks and download one of them for free.
And finally
for today, treat yourself and try this song Show Me the Place,
a new song from Leonard Cohen with some familiar religious imagery. All
choir voices on this track were composed and performed by Jennifer
Warnes, my favourite singer!
18/11/11
Last time round I wasn't too enamoured with Rev., BBC's comedy
drama about a Church of England vicar. When it returned for a new season
last Thursday night on BBC 2 I thought I'd give it a second look. The
programme opened with the Rev, played by Tom Hollander, saying what seemed
like heartfelt prayers while on retreat. So far so good, you don't see
too many people praying on TV drama. (The next startling innovation should
be a lay person praying!) The episode got a bit silly then when the Rev
was treated as a hero because he was wrongly credited with tackling a
mugger. At least this led to a worthy scene where his rationalising about
accepting an award crumbled in a conversation with the Bishop of London
- a charismatic cameo by Ralph Fiennes. Another plot strand about a school
tour was more troubling. I got the impression that the show was struggling
towards some insight when the Rev was called a "pedo" in the street and
when he was struggling with huge child protection requirements for the
tour. But there was a cheap shot at the Catholic Church - suggesting that
you'd certainly need the protective measures if a Catholic school was
involved. Admittedly the man making the slur was a dodgy character, but
then in the "happy ending" the same character went off with the children
on the outing despite child protection warnings, and the last shot saw
the children and himself making obscene gestures from the back of the
minibus. It left a queasy feeling, and there were some unnecessary crude
elements as well, as if someone felt they had to make it "edgy".
12/11/11
Great to see
Rita Connolly singing the Deer's Cry, by Shaun Davey based on the
payer of St Patrick, at the inauguration of Michael D Higgins as President.
Very soulful.
8/11/11 I seem to have my TY class rather intermittently, what with special
workshop days, matches and other distractions! As indicated below somewhere
I'm doing religion and music with the students. Today I used some
songs suggested by an enthusiastic student, even if the religious content
was rather peripheral. Living on a Prayer by Bon Jovi was popular
with the students joining in on the chorus. Bon Jovi's Keep the Faith
was more complex, relatively speaking, and I definitely had
to provide lyric sheets as it was hard to make out the words. One I wasn't
familiar with at all was Prayin' by Plan B (video top left), a
rather unusual song about guilt and redemption. The lyrics of these are
readily available online and there are any number of versions on YouTube
- I used video versions as it holds the attention of students more than
just a CD. Ah, the lost talent of just listening!
Last Sunday
I was present for the live broadcast of Sunday Mass on RTE from
the parish of Sts Mary and Peter in Arklow. The occasion was the 150th
anniversary of the parish, and some of this history was outlined briefly
in a video lead in. One of the encouraging facts outlined was there are
over 700 lay people involved in parish ministries. I had to catch up on
this video intro later as those of us in the church just got to hear the
audio only. The church was mostly full for the occasion, and it was great
to see many young people, not just in the congregation but taking a more
active part in music and readings. Indeed the music was one of the more
impressive features of the event, with a gospel choir on one side of the
church, and a more traditional mixed choir on the other. The attractiveness
of the music was enhanced by the poetic first reading - from the Book
of Wisdom - and the sung responsorial Psalm was haunting - "Like a
deer that y earns for running streams". Admittedly it was rather distracting
to have all those cameras and lights in the church, and disconcerting
to think that you might be on camera to the world at any stage and not
know it. I've used the video of the Mass several times in class since
then - to illustrate aspects of the Mass and of the local parish.
19/10/11
Today I tried out the first of the Mission Sunday prayer services.
I used the songs mentioned below (entry for 13/10/11) along with Go
Tell It on the Mountain from James Taylor's excellent Christmas album,
and Salt and Light from the album "Songs From the Loft"
(a great addition for any RE Dept). I took most of the prayers and readings
from the resources sent to schools by the Irish Missionary Union (these
can be downloaded from www.imu.ie) - click
on the "Mission Alive" link.
13/10/11 Next week I'm planning to take classes to the prayer room for
a service relating to Mission Sunday (Oct 23rd). So far I think
I'll use I Send You Out and By Name I have Called You by
John Angotti, along with Here I Am Lord (I have a version on CD
by John Michael Talbot from his album Table of Plenty). Any other
suggestions? If I get time I'll make up a special web page for mission
theme resources.
Last Sunday
I went to the Brooke Fraser concert in the Academy in Middle Abbey
St Dublin. Fraser is a singer-songwriter from New Zealand who has written
and sung with the well known gospel group Hillsong. Now she is pursuing
a solo career with songs that are not specifically gospel, though I believe
she still writes for Hillsong. Her songs on the night were very melodic,
her band was really good, but the main problem was that I found that the
words were very hard to make out. Whether this was because of sound quality
on the night or her lack of articulation or becuase her voice was being
swamped by the band I'm not sure. The opposite was the case with the Angotti
concert reviewed below. If the message is important I think it's important
to be able to make out the words.
9/10/11
Ha! There's an interesting date. One of my students said he was looking
forward to this, pity we're not in school today.
I notice that The Way, that film starring Martin Sheen with the
Camino de Santiago pilgrimage as backdrop, has recently been released
in the USA - we got to see it back in May (see my review here
, entry for 29/5/11). The film is due out on DVD on the 31st October.
There's a perceptive review by Steven D. Greydanus at the National Catholic
Register (click here),
while over at the US Catholic News Service there's an interesting review
by John Mulderig (click here).
8/10/11 Last Wednesday night my PC played TV for an hour as I watched
a live concert streamed on the web from California. The artist was US
singer-songwriter John Angotti who toured here this time last year
- we were lucky to have him do a concert in our school - it was one of
the highlights of the year.
The label "Christian Rock" doesn't do him justice as his appeal is much
broader, and his songs can often be found in liturgical settings - some
of his work was featured in last year's Emmanuel event for school choirs.
With a voice like Elton John and a knack for appealing melodies he is
one of the outstanding Catholic performers in this field. Last week's
web concert was from St Monica's High School in Santa Monica and the young
students provided not only an attentive audience, but a fine vocal backing
choir, perfectly complementing Angotii's classy band. However the heart
of the performance was the singer's own voice and piano. The set started
and finished with the catchy refrain "I send you out on a mission of love",
there was a new version of "Make Me a Channel of Your Peace", and I particularly
liked the moving "By Name I Have Called You". For all songs the words
were crystal clear, essential when singing about the Word.
Between songs Angotti encouraged the young students not to be influenced
by what others regarded as "cool". The world might offer lots of distraction,
but the only thing that didn't end was love, and love sometimes moved
us beyond our comfort zones. I liked the catchphrase "we can be bitter
or we can choose to be better", and his notion that the music in heaven
will be Bach and Hendrix! He stressed the important role of mystery, suggesting
that if we were given the whole mystery we would only try to control it.
The concert doesn't seem to be available for playback, but there is plenty
of concert footage from Angotti on YouTube (e.g. clip on left, recorded
at the RE Congress in Los Angeles 2010). And he said he hopes to back
in Ireland next June. His albums are well worth getting and should be
useful in many school contexts.
30/9/11
Continuing the module on Religion and Music with Transition Year,
I used the song Stairway to Heaven by Led Zepplin as this had been
suggested by a student the previous week. Not sure how religious this
is - I'd never paid much attention to the lyrics before and they're rather
obscure, but with a few possible religious references included. In the
same class I also included God Bless the Artists by The Roches
(could be the theme song for Faitharts!) and Shot Down by Larry
Norman (an excellent version by Michael Anderson). The latter song tells
of the stick Larry Norman got from some Christians when he first started
mixing the gospel with rock music. Have yet to read over the students'
comments on the songs - will report back here soon. The songs can be sourced
on sites like iTunes and 7Digital, or streamed from We7, Grooveshark,
Eircom Music Hub etc
28/9/11
Earlier tonight I got to attend one of Liam Lawton's workshops on his
new Glandalough Mass, including settings that incorporate the new
Mass texts. The event was across the road in my local parish of Templerainey,
Arklow. I expected to observe but ended up singing in the men's section
- I think I got the hang of the melody lines, but as for the men's harmonies,
I was a slow learner! I thought the music was very appealing, from the
soulful Kyrie to the uptempo Glory to God. One of my favourites
was one of the proclamations of the mystery of faith, Save Us, Saviour
of the World. It was a great insight into the creative to hear Liam
outlining some of the reasons for various musical choices he had made.
I like his encouragement to choirs to sing only the melody lines for a
few weeks, so that congregations would get used to them, and not be put
off joining in by harmonies being introduced too early. The evening ended,
suitably, with a prayer, accompanied by piano player Mark who was effective
but unobtrusive for the whole workshop.
25/911 Had
my first class with Transition Year last week and first off I'm doing
my module on religion and music. There's so much material out there,
but each year I like to rely on a combination old favourites and new material.
I lways find Amy Grant's version of What About the Love (by Janis
Ian and Kyle Fleming) goes down well. It has a powerful message and a
great final verse. I've added the song in video form on left above. When
Will We Ever Learn to Live in God, a Van Morrison/Cliff Richard duet
also went down, thank's I'd say to the catchy rhythm. A more challenging
song I tried was Now is the Time for Tears by Charlie Peacock from
the "Coram Deo" album (a brilliant music resource for RE). Most
if not all these songs are available on download or streaming sites like
iTunes, 7Digital, We7, Eircom Music Hub etc.
6/9/11
Today I came across a blog post "What's
the Problem with Christian Rock". I sympathise with some of what
the writer Marc Barnes is saying - - he thinks the average Christian Rock
song , as played by Christian radio stations is weak and imitative, not
worthy of its subject matter. But I still like Larry Norman, Mark Heard,
Randy Stonehill and early John Michael Talbot. These were always a cut
above the average anyway. Apart from the article, the follow up comments
are well worth reading for anyone with an interest in the area.
30/8/11 The Courageous Heart of Irena Sendler, a film shown on RTE
in the early hours of last Thursday, told the inspiring and true story
of a Catholic social worker in Nazi-occupied Warsaw who smuggled Jewish
children out of the ghetto to save them from deportation to extermination
camps. Anna Paquin, a former child actor who has made a fine transition
into adult roles, played Sendler, and was the emotional heart of the film.
While it lacked the dramatic intensity of Polanski's The Pianist,
one thing the film did well was to show the internal conflicts among the
Jews about whether they should let their children be looked after by Polish
families who would pretend the children were Catholic. Some couldn't let
go emotionally, some couldn't believe that the cultured Germans could
plan such a fate for the Jews, some feared their children might be converted,
though Sendler stressed that this wasn't her intention.
Though it was somewhat slow in developing the story in the early stages,
there were some heart-rending moments, especially when children were separated
from their parents, even to save them. There was an especially unsettling
scene as children were rounded up from the ghetto orphanages - they went
off singing as they thought they were going to a better place. The bleak
faces of the adults and Sendler's frustration told a different story.
Nazi
atrocities were not that graphically portrayed, though the atmosphere
of fear was well conveyed. The worst sequence was the interrogation of
Sendler by the Gestapo.
As for specifically religious content, it was unobtrusive. The local priest
was seen helping Sendler, convents were seen to be hiding Jewish children,
respect
was shown to the Jewish tradition - there was no intention to convert
the children, and Sendler kept records so that the children could, if
possible, be reunited with their own families after the war.
Scenes that would be useful in class include a Seder meal, a family discussion
on whether the children should be hidden with Christian families, an early
scene where some of Sendler's co-workers can't bring themselves to help
the Jews because of prejudice (see clip above, which also features other
useful scenes). A
Jewish community scene also discusses the issue of what to do with the
children and raises the difficult of lying to stay alive e.g. documents
are forged, Jewish children pretend to be Christian by learning to bless
themselves and say Christian prayers - mental reservation anyone?
As the film ends there's a touching addition where the real Sendler speaks
about the Jewish mothers who gave
up their children and the Christian mothers who risked their lives to
save them. She died in 2008 at the age of 98!
For more information on Irena Sendler, including educational resources,
go here: http://www.irenasendler.com/
25/8/11
I'm glad to say the arts figured strongly in the World Youth Day ceremonies
in Madrid last weekend. And fortunately it's possible to look back on
some of these events online. The music of the opening Mass on the Tuesday
and the closing Mass last Sunday was superb I thought - massed choirs
and orchestra, composed largely of young people. The Way of the Cross
last Friday wasn't as striking as that in Sydney three years ago, but
the scupltures used were quite striking. I liked what Pope Benedict said
about them: "In these images, faith and art combine so as to penetrate
our heart and summon us to conversion. When faith's gaze is pure and authentic,
beauty places itself at its service and is able to depict the mysteries
of our salvation in such a way as to move us profoundly and transform
our hearts". Ireland's Dana sang at one session, the band L'Angelus
from USA played a set at one of the venues as did John Angotti. You can
look back on some of these events at wydcentral, click here
and scroll down for the video archive.
22/8/11
On Monday of last week RTE broadcast the annual Eurovision Mass for
the Feast of the Assumption, this time from Fribourg in Switzerland.
I love Masses in French and the choral and orchestral music was fine as
expected, but the introduction was a pleasant surprise, with some background
information on the area, especially relating to religious artists whose
work featured during the ceremony. The area also hosts a museum of stained
glass, and we got to see people doing restoration work on these. During
the ceremony the camera often lingered on the beautiful windows in the
church. We got to see the artist Marcel Dorthe at work and one of his
artworks of Mary figured prominently in the coverage, as it was set up
in the church for the occasion. Well worth a look - at the time of writing
the programme is still available to view here.
9/8/11 Finally I get back to blogging. About two weeks ago I went to
see the L'Angelus sacred hymns concert in Carrig-on-Bannow as part
of the annual Phil Murphy Weekend. Great that this long-running summer
festival should include a faith element (there was also an Ó Riada
Mass). The group performed some old favourites from last year and some
new songs - including the haunting "Were You There" (clip on
left). For some songs they were joined by their mother Linda and little
brothers and sisters. The band kindly allowed me to film the event and
I hope to add some more songs soon - check out "faithartswebsite"
on YouTube, where there are also songs from last year's concert.
12/7/11 (to view clip without leaving this page hover mouse over bottom of
picture and click play button bottom left)
The Tree
of Life: director Terrence Malick specialises in reflective storylines,
interesting characters and stunning visuals. The Tree of Life includes
all these but the emphasis is not so much on plot this time, which makes
for challenging viewing. It's a long film (about 2 hours 20 mins), it's
episodic like a series of memories, the timeline isn't chronological,
the viewer will have to work hard to make sense of it at times, but I'd
say the patient, reflective viewer will find it rewarding. The plot, which
is only one aspect of this complex film, concerns a family in USA in the
1950's - the father (Brad Pitt) loves his wife (Jessica Chastain) and
children but is gruff and rather domineering. This causes problems for
his three sons, one of whom, Jack (Sean Penn) we see in his later adult
life, trying to find meaning. The film was most appealing to me in the
family life scenes, but these scenes are just fragments, only sometimes
approaching "normal" film style.
The acting throughout was superb - Pitt can be both appealing and off-putting
as the father, Chastain is the moral and emotional core of the film as
the mother, Sean Penn doesn't have a lot to do, while the child actors
are excellent, especially Hunter McCracken as the young Jack.
The visuals are beautiful - the camera lingers lovingly (boringly, I'm
sure some will say!) on water, skyscapes, sunflowers. These visuals are
accompanied subtly by light classical music, and overall the clarity of
the picture is exceptional - see it on Blu-Ray when it comes out on DVD!
There is a strong faith element, but it's more reflective than preachy.
The Book of Job figures strongly (the film starts with a quote
from the book) and a variety of prayers and scriptural quotations graces
the film. Some of the background music is religious as well - e.g. there's
a striking Agnus Dei at a particularly significant moment.
Big meaning of life questions are raised and answers are only hinted at.
The issue of human suffering is tackled, mainly through the efforts of
Jack to make sense of what he has learned about God and the world. The
father is a religious man, but it seems too much on the surface, while
with the mother it's a more internal thing. Her opening voiceover (clip
above), on what she has learned about the difference between nature and
grace is crucial to an understanding of the film's themes.
Needless to say I was wondering how this might be used in school. Certainly
I can't see myself showing the full film - I'd suspect students might
mitch to avoid it! But there are some useful clips - e.g. the opening
voiceover of the mother, a scene where young Jack is praying, a sermon
in church, a scene near the end that may be a representation of Heaven.
One could fault the film for its perfunctory plot, its overuse of lingering
pretty pictures, its excessive length,. Some critics have accused it of
being ponderous and pretentious (which I wouldn't agree with). Yet it
gives the impression that it was well thought out and that everything
is the way it is for a good reason. The one thing I'd be less inclined
to make allowances for is the difficulty at times of making out what the
characters are saying - what with the regional accents and the mumbling
and whispering. There's little enough dialogue, so I would have thought
it should be clearer. I'd be inclined to activate the subtitles when I
get the DVD.
The more I think about the film the more I find I want to see it again,
and that wasn't my first reaction. I think it's one of those films that
call for a second viewing - there's just too much to take in first time
around.
Got
to Italy on holidays last week, and I was struck more than ever
before about the how casually there's so much religious art around. Of
course you can get it in the museums and famous sites, but there was an
ambundance of it even in the smallest and most obscure churches you'd
stumble on. We were in the Lake Como area and the hillsides leading down
to the lake were dotted with little churches, monuments, monoasteries.
It wasn't always allowed to take photos, but I'm including here a pic
of a rather distinctive Baptismal font from a church in Bellagio. It might
be useful for projects/classes on Baptism - higher resolution version
available on request, along with one of the font on its own. There was
a painting of the Baptism of Jesus right above the font.
26/6/11
Yesterday I got to the Art/Faith Forum Conference in Dublin - plenty
of thought provoking ideas there, not to mention quite a few artists and
poets. The conference title was "The Baptised Imagination" and
the whole idea of the religious imagination was central to the event.
Main speaker in the morning was Fr Michael Paul Gallagher SJ who has written
many books about the interface of faith and culture. It was a deep and
complex talk and I'll try to get hold of the text for more in-depth reflection.
He quoted Cardinal Newan's comments "The heart is commonly reached,
not through the reason, but through the imagination" (find the context
of this observation here).
Colette Clarke gave a presentation on the art of iconography and displayed
several appealing examples of the genre, and flagged the work of the Association
of Iconographers of Ireland (more info here).
In the afternoon there was another interesting talk, this time from Gregory
Wolfe an American author and editor of "Image
- a Journal of the Arts and Religion".
16/6/11 I've
been a fan of Jennifer Warnes for years - the first album of hers I bought
was just titled "Jennifer Warnes" and among other great songs
she sang Oh God of Loveliness (clip on left). Her most famous album
is "Famous Blue Raincoat" when she recorded some of the songs
of Leonard Cohen, and some she co-wrote with him. This album included
the beautiful Song of Bernadette (see video
page) and Joan of Arc. She has also recorded some traditional Christmas
songs which featured on a Hallmark Christmas album some years ago. Her
most recent album is The Well and one could certainly find some
Biblical imagery in the title track, though it's not overt and may not
even have been intended. A new album is apparently in the works. For a
sampler of her work there's always a selection of songs playing on her
website www.jenniferwarnes.com
7/6/11 On Sunday last
RTE 1 broadcast Mass for the Ascension, live and outdoors from
the Claddagh in Galway city. The music was provided by the Tribal Chamber
Choir - their selections from Haydn and Handel were excellent but didn't
facilitate congregational singing! However the small congregation did
join in on Ár nAthair and the recessional Praise My Soul the
King of Heaven. You can look back on this programme here
and for a while on the RTE
Player.
Religious
music was also to the fore on Songs of Praise, BBC 1's long running
show, which provides a comfortable kind of spirituality. Last Sunday Eamonn
Holmes presented the show from Northern Ireland, where Daniel O'Donnell
was one of the contributors - he sang a fine acoustic version of "Here
I Am Lord", with just guitar accompaniment, while the choir at a Presbyterian
church (Hamilton Road, Bangor I think) sang well throughout the programme.
I really enjoyed Artist Ross Wilson's few words on C.S. Lewis, and his
visually arresting wardrobe sculpture was a fitting tribute to the author
- Lewis' letter to a young reader explaining the Christian allegory of
his Narnia books was also inscribed on the work.
Later that
night BBC 1 Wales carried the first part of The Passion of Port Talbot,
an intriguing documentary on a community based passion play in the Welsh
town that had suffered over the years from poor development. The initiative
was led by local man, Michael Sheen, now a famous actor (he played Tony
Blair in The Queen)but it seemed he mainly wanted to tell the story
of Port Talbot using the Jesus story as a vehicle, complete with crucifixion
scene. At one stage he said this was all he wanted to do, but later when
local clergy became uneasy about the direction the play was taking, he
did listen and reassure them that it actually was the story of Jesus (in
the guise of "The Teacher"), told in a different way. Fascinating theatrically,
but I thought it felt somewhat empty spiritually. The performance itself
will feature in part 2 this Sunday night.
29/5/11 Finally got to see The Way last night, and I wasn't disappointed.
This new film is about a father-son relationship and is set against the
background of the Camino de Santiago pilgrimage in Spain. Martin Sheen
plays the father, while his son Emilio Estevez plays the son, and also
wrote and directed.
It was quite moving, challenging and thought provoking. Gradually we get
to know the Sheen character and the motley crew he meets up with. It's
a strongly human film, and its empathy with the characters is what makes
it involving and touching. The Pilgrimage motif is of course a powerful
one - the journey through life, the baggage we carry apart from our backpacks,
the varying paths we take, the people we journey with. Estevez uses the
motif subtly enough, but may have been worried about critical reaction
as he has the Irish writer (played by James Nesbitt) revel in the "metaphor
bonanza" and yet wonder if he is being over fanciful - things may be what
they seem and no more than that. Perhaps Estevez wishes to distance himself
from having an overly religious film - at one stage a minor character
says it's not about religion at all, and stresses the point. None of the
characters makes an obvious connection with God in any way, yet the film
is imbued, in a positive way, with religion, without being heavy handed
in any way. The Sheen character prays, though at the beginning he doesn't
see the point. In a key scene the woman struggles with prayer. Churches
and religious images abound, and there are at least two positive priest
characters.
There are some fine set pieces, and such scenes may well be useful in
RE, though the full film is probably too long and leisurely for youngsters.
Near the start a French policeman explains the nature of the pilgrimage,
and later, on the road, the pilgrims discuss the nature of the "true pilgrim"
(both clips useful in classes on pilgrimage). For symbolism there's a
scene at one point where the tradition is to say a prayer and leave a
stone at a particular monument (useful for ritual as well). The scene
where they arrive at the cathedral in Santiago de Compostella is really
well done, and really captures a sense of awe and wonder. Among the interesting
conversations on the road, one has a subtle pro-life message as a woman
wonders about her unborn baby. Some elements raise questions of suitability
for young viewers - in particular there's an ambiguous attitude to soft
drugs, but I think it will give mature viewers a warm glow. Many films
deal with journeys (physical and metaphorical) of self discovery but The
Way has carved out a distinctive little niche of its own.
In
the last few days I've been showing parts of the film Sophie Scholl,
The Final Days, with 3rd Year students. (Sophie Scholl was a real
life character who campaigned against the Nazis in Germany - she was arrested
for leafletting). It fits in really well with the morality element of
the course. I even used the clip on left as past of my assessment with
the TY students. This clip is the final interrogation of Sophie, and the
script is based on transcripts of the original interrogation. One could
get several classes out of this ten-minute clip - issues raised include
conscience, the state and religion, empathy, world view, persecution of
the Jews and the mentally ill, and God. Sophie is a great role model for
young people, but even the interrogator is an interesting character. I
was glad to see the third years absorbed by this, as there's a lot of
talk, and it's subtitled.
19/5/11 We had a visit from the Diocesan Advisor earlier this
week for presentation of certificates from the Diocese in recognition
for the students' work in RE during the year. We've opted for this scheme
for the last few years and I think it's a great way to give some positive
feedback to the students. Some of them spoke enthusiastically about their
work, some did not! As part of the course students were required to produced
a work of art with religious themes, and some displayed their wares on
the day. The results varied.... There were a few hurried drawings, a few
interesting poems, a visual presentaion on the moving statues phenomenon
of the 80's and some music. Looking back on the year most had positive
memories of their retreat with Net Ministries and the concert with John
Angotti back in September. Tomorrow is the start of their RE assessment
- questions on a poem (I've chosen Love by George Herbert) and
a song that I'll play for them (on CD I hasten to add)- God Bless the
Artists by the Roches (see clip above left), an appropriate end to
a module on religion and the arts.
14/5/11
Will hopefully be on Spirit Radio this coming Monday around 10.25
or so. Should have been last Monday but technical hitches got in the way.
This week I hope to be reviewing the newly released film The Way
starring Martin Sheen.
Was doing
the Edmund Rice story just after Easter (May 5th is his day) and got a
lot of mileage out of artist Desmond Kyne's wonderful Icon of Edmund Rice.
We have a copy in the school hall, but the folks at ERST produced a special
Powerpoint version that takes students through all the panels of the icon.
Among other resources when doing the Resurrection I used
this year for the first time the Resurrection scene (see clip from this
on left) at the end of The Miracle Maker, the beautifully animated
version of the life of Jesus. Apart from a few giggles at Mary Magdalen's
very emotional reactions (I teach boys) it seemed to hold the attention.
Several clips from this film can be viewed (and downloaded if you subscribe
to the free account or higher) on the relevant
Wingclips page. I also got students drawing their own Resurrection
scenes - some interesting images resulted, many having Jesus exclaiming
"I'm back!"
3/5/11 Last Saturday night in the National Concert Hall I got to see
The Armed Man - A Mass for Peace, a striking work by Welsh composer
Karl Jenkins. I had seen it before in Cork, but this time Jenkins himself
conducted and it was accompanied by film clips to illustrate its powerful
message of peace amidst all the war and militarism, mostly of the 20th
Century. The orchestra and choirs were great, but I found myself mostly
absorbed by the film clips - quite a saddening panorama of our times,
but after all the menace and violence the piece certainly ends on a calming,
peaceful and hopeful note. This performance will be repeated in the University
of Limerick on Sunday 8th May. One of the movements is the Benedictus,
and the clip on left gives a flavour of the experience though it's not
from Saturday's performance.
29/4/11
Just came across an intriguing article, where Jennifer Fulwiler, a blogger
and Catholic convert, list her ten favourite Rap songs. The title of the
article caught my eye - "Top 10 Rap Songs for Catholics "!
Rap is not one of my favourite music genres but every class we teach has
probably got a few rap fans (and probably a few who can't stand it!).
I remember having one student who was constantly referencing Tupac, and
I notice that one of his songs is on the list. This kind of music often
gets a bad rap (!) for bad language and violent lyrics, but Fulwiler has
navigated her way to what seems likes some interesting material. Click
here
to read the article.
28/4/11 On
Tuesday night last I headed up to Tobar
Mhuire, the Passionist Monastery in Crossgar Co. Down to hear a L'Angelus
concert. Unfortunately the band didn't do any gigs down south during
this mini-tour (back in July, and doing World Youth Day in August)), but
it was certainly worth the trip up north. As usual the band gave a great
show, and their new songs were well up to standard. The old standards
were on the setlist too, and along with the good-time Cajun songs they
performed some of their sacred repertoire - including Be Thou My Vision,
Ave Maria, and those beautiful watlzes - The Waltz of St Cecila
and The Waltz of the Sorrowful Mysteries. It was an appropriate
venue for these songs as it was in the multi purpose room that mainly
serves as the church for the Passionist Community in Crossgar. Thanks
to Fr John and the other members of the community for the excellent hospitality
and the sing song that followed the gig for those staying over.
The monastery also featured a striking Stations of the Cross - figures
arranged in the recesses of girders sunk into the courtyard - very effective.
For St Patrick's Day I made up a slide show of images of the saint - now
I've a new one to add - the rather modern sculpture of the saint on the
way out of Downpatrick - pic above.
25/4/11
While passion plays have a long history, it was inevitable that the movies
would eventually tell the story of Jesus. The first feature length version,
"From the Manger to the Cross" (1912) was the subject of the documentary
First Passion, on TG4 last week. It was intriguing on many levels
- there were clips from the movie, and while I would like to have seen
more, they were rather melodramatic as usual for silent movies, and it
was strange that a film about The Word featured so few words! In a move
that was revolutionary for its time they shot the film in the original
Holy Land locations. One contributor suggested that this was partly to
provide American audiences with a sort of virtual pilgrimage of the area.
Robert Henderson-Bland played Jesus and wrote extensively about it. The
role had a profound effect on him, some even said it unhinged him, but
he went on to become a decorated World War I hero.
As cinema at the time was widely regarded as a gimmick, the venture was
regarded as potentially blasphemous by some and efforts were made to diffuse
criticism - for example scripture quotes were displayed on screen between
some of the scenes. Cinemas were given tips as to how to create a respectful
atmosphere - no eating, drinking or laughing! In fact the programme made
out that the film had an impact on how cinema audiences in general responded
to cinema, as it was longer and more serious than what the average audience
was used to. Pre-screenings were given to clergy and posters carried an
"endorsed by the clergy" tag - surely the kiss of death for any film today!
And this despite the fact that there wasn't a resurrection scene. As regards
school use I could see myself using some of this documentary in class
- as part of the films and religion module in Transition Year I look at
the issues relating to films about Jesus and this certainly a trailblazer
of the genre.
At the time of writing the documentary is still available to watch on
the TG4 website in three segments - for the first part click here.
22/4/11 Passion
in the Pale (RTE 1 last night) was a most absorbing and entertaining
programme. The main element was coverage of a passion play performed in
the streets of Dublin in 2010. Good to see the passion play tradition
getting such a fresh treatment, and good to see the whole process for
the actors and director starting with a gospel reading. As often happens
with such a venture, some of the actors spoke of being quite moved by
taking part. Watching the rehearsals was fascinating, and on performance
day the rain added to the sad atmosphere - the tears of wailing women
around Jesus blended in particularly well. Another striking touch was
the way the cross was sitting on the Last Supper table - effective but
unnerving! Running parallel to this was a performance of St Matthew's
Passion by Bach in the Pro-Cathedral, with orchestra and several choirs,
including loads of youngsters. I'm not sure that the two elements of the
film blended or were balanced together that well, but the common passion
motif did provide a degree of unity, and all in all film maker Patrick
Butler who wrote, edited and produced this work deserves our gratitude
and compliments. I can see myself using this, or parts of it at least
when I do the drama section of my Religion and Arts module with Transition
Year class next year. Unfortunately it doesn't seem to be available on
the RTE Player.
17/4/11
I
got to see a preview of new film There Be Dragons, on the Spanish
Civil War and the early days of St Josemaria Escriva, founder of Opus
Dei. I'll post a more detailed review nearer the time for its Irish release.
Directed by Roland Joffé (The Mission, The Killing Fields), it's
quite inspiring, thought-provoking, even poetic at times, with really
creative use of imagery. And there are times when it sad, and even unsettling.
The most prominent theme is that of forgiveness, and there are many scenes
useful for Religious Education - e.g. on forgiveness, Eucharist, Reconciliation
(there's a great clandestine confession scene in a zoo!). THE IMDB Entry
for the film is here.
13/4/11 Was
back on Spirit Radio last Monday - it's now a monthly slot with
more time available - 2nd Monday of the month sometime 10.20 to 10.40.
Last Monday presenter Ronan Johnston and I discussed Josh Groban's new
album Iluminations (pic on left) - some spiritual imagery in there,
including in Declan O'Rourke's song "Galileo". I'll post full
review of that album shortly. I wasn't much into Groban's music but this
album is impressive - excellent production by Rick Rubin, who has worked
with a wide range of artists, from Johnny Cash to Slayer!
We also discussed a CD I picked up at the weekend - Laudate features
Taizé music recorded in Gort Mhuire in Dublin. - originally it
came out on cassette but I hadn't got my own copy, so I was thrilled to
find one copy in Veritas Cork last weekend. It's one of the best Taizé
albums and I've already used it in class.
I flagged the forthcoming John Michael Talbot album, Worship and Bow
Down due out in June (see News page) and was glasd that Ronan was
familiar with his work, and also a great fan like myself.
I was able to talk about the Emmanuel concert I attended recently, and
the Teen SpiriT concerts in Cork and Kerry featured on Nationwide of 6th
April (may be available on the RTE
Player.
Finally I recommended the new film There Be Dragons - more of that
on the blog in a day or two.
1/4/11 Today
I got to use my first film clip downloaded from Wingclips
- a brilliant web resource where you can watch and download readymade
film clips on a huge range of themes. The clip I used (included above)
was of the Last Supper from The Miracle Maker. It is animated
but done really well. This was available in the free section of the site
and though it was supposed to be low quality I was very happy with it
- I played it full screen from a data projector. The clip downloaded in
a format that Windows Media Player can handle, so it was convenient. We
had already used the equivalent sequence from Jesus of Nazareth
and the students had been drawing their own Last Supper scenes (heavinly
influenced by Leonardo!). There were a few giggles at the animated apostles,
but it held the attention.
24/3/11
Last night I got to experience the opening night of Emmanuel 2011
in the Helix. It was brilliant - around 700 students singing their hearts
out as they performed a wide range of liturgical music from plain chant
to modern gospel. Our own school had a group included so I was glad to
be able to support them. Students had been praticing the music for a few
months in school and yesterday was the first time they came together.
Christ Among Us by David Haas set the tone, Lord I Want to Be
a Christian was an African spiritual and featured some good solos
and tasty guitar work. Irish composers were well represented, including
Ronan McDonagh, Liam Lawton, Bernard Sexton and Ian Callanan who directed
the choirs and got to blow out a birthday cake at the end. Apart from
his own compositions, including the touching Warm Embrace, he had
arranged some of the material, e.g. A Mhuire Mháthair. The
audience got a chance to join in especially on Come Bring Your Burdens
to God where we had to learn three-part harmony on the spot. Things
livened up big-time in the second half, starting with I Will Follow
Him from Sister Act. We got a taste of the theme song for the upcoming
Eucharistic Congress - Though We Are Many by Bernard Sexton. Trading
My Sorrows by Darrell Evans had everybody joining in the hand gestures,
while Thanks and Praise by John Angotti and Ed Boldne had all the
students standing swaying and clapping. Go Out and Tell by Bobby
Fisher and Greg Lee was the perfect song to finish, sending us all out
on a high! Fr Pat O'Donohue, Dublin Diocese Director of Music called on
anyone involved in parishes to let this music and these students uplift
our liturgies. Amen to that!
22/3/11 Web
TV served me well last weekend as I was able to watch the Religious
Education Congress from Annaheim in the Diocese of Los Angeles from
the comfort of home. I was particularly impressed by the music, in performances
and liturgies. Our own Liam Lawton, along with Tony Alonso conducted one
presentation, "Castle of the Soul", on the Saturday - it was beautiful.
Earlier we got to hear the Jacob and Matthew Band, who provided the lively
theme song from the Congress, "People Rise Up". There was also a reference
to a Jazz Mass, but unfortunately that wasn't featured in the webcast.
The music at the closing liturgy with new Archbishop José Gomez was particularly
striking, as was the whole event. There was much liturgical dancing, which
I found distracting, but it certainly was graceful and respectful. Clip
on left shows Opening Ceremony.
12/3/11 Last
night I got to see The Rite, the latest film with a exorcism theme.
In terms of that genre it is well made, literate, and is boosted by an
intense performance by Anthony Hopkins as an old exorcist. Much of the
film is about the struggle between doubt and faith, especially in a young
seminarian, but the film is strongly supportive of faith. I can't see
much use for it in RE class though as the material is quite disturbing,
and the tone is unrelentingly serious. The exorcism scenes aren't all
that graphic by modern standards, but thery are unsettling, especially
as the main character who is possessed is a young girl pregnant from incest.
It is thought provoking for a very mature audience, but you have to remind
yourself that it's entertainment as well and there are some clichéd
and OTT elements (room full of frogs for example!).
On last Monday's
interview on Spirit Radio I discussed a recent film Paul. It tells
the story of a foul-mouthed alien who meets two sci-fi nerds played by
Simon Pegg and Nick Frost (from Hot Fuzz and Shawn of the Dead).
I wanted to like it, and there were some funny moments, but the crudenesss
and bad language was way over the top. Worse still there was at times
a sneering and dismissive attitude to religious faith. The particular
target was a creationist family - the father is a rough bible-and-shotgun-totin'
redneck, while the daughter, who thinks the very existence of the alien
contradicts the Bible and so resolves to make up for her years of piety
with some intense sinning and swearing. Definitely leaves a sour taste
17/2/11
Got to speak on Spirit Radio last Monday - I was interviewed about
faith and the arts on Ronan Johnston's morning show. Discussed some films,
Of God's and Men and The King's Speech, Ashley Cleveland's
performance in the Transatlantic Sessions and various issues relating
to teaching RE and English. Looks like it will become a weekly slot -
around 10.30 am on Mondays. (I hide away in my classroom during a free
class!) Spirit Radio is on FM in the main cities (On FM in Dublin 89.9
- Limerick 89.8 - Galway 91.7 - Cork 90.9 - Waterford 90.1) and online.
There's also an iPhone app, and it's on the Nokia Internet Radio app (available
free from the OVI store).
9/2/11
Have been doing the miracles of Jesus for the last few days with
second year students. The students seem quite clued in and are familiar
with many miracles. I've been showing various clips of these from films
on the life of Jesus - for example there's a good portrayal of the raising
of Lazarus in the Gospel of John film, featuring Henry Ian Cusick
as Jesus (he played Desmond in Lost). From Jesus of Nazareth
I used clips of the miraculous catch of fish (very striking visually),
the healing of the paralysed man (which follows soon after), the raising
of the daughter of Jairus, the miracle of the loaves and fishes and the
healing of the blind man. As well as that I've been getting the students
to illustrate their choice of the miracles of Jesus.
6/2/11 I
finally got to see the film Of Gods and Men (Des Hommes et Des
Dieux) , still drawing crowds at the Lighthouse Cinema in Smithfield,
Dublin. This tells the true story of a group of Cistercian monks under
threat from Islamist terrorists in Algeria. It's a slow moving drama but
well worth the effort to stay with it. Rarely have I seen a film with
such depth of faith and respect for its subject. It's not in the least
bit preachy or sentimental, but treats the deepest of religious themes
in an accessible but challenging way. Unless you know the historical background
very well it's entirely unpredictable - I couldn't help thinking at various
stages that Hollywood would treat it so differently, but thankfully it
avoids clichés and stereotypes.
The characters of the monks is what appeals most as they try to serve
the local Muslim population with respect and compassion. The increasing
terrorist violence in the areas puts them on edge as they grapple with
internal and external conflicts, agonising over whether they should stay
and risk all or leave to save themselves.
I couldn't see myself showing the whole film in class, because it's so
slow moving and so much requiring maturity in the viewer (there's also
a rather graphic killing), but there are several scenes that might work
well. For example, the scene where they get their first visit from the
terrorists is particular striking and tense, and features an unusual bit
of impromptu inter-faith dialogue! Later the monks sing together (as they
do regularly in the film) in an act of solidarity as a military helicopter
hovers menacingly overhead. A scene where they finally decide what to
do is also of interest, while near the end there's a touching letter from
one of the monks about the relationships between Christians and Muslims.
Several scenes show the monks in intense moments of prayer.
What remained with me most was the individuals and their relationships
- the character of each monk is portrayed beautifully, and the film stands
as a tribute to their human dignity, cameraderie, courage and faith.
The film has been held over at the Lighthouse much longer than expected
due to public demand - significant that a challenging film with religion
so central should develop such a following.
This weekend's
Irish Times features an excellent article "Can Modern Art
Keep the Faith", by Gemma Tipton. This piece looks at the the
relationship between art and religion in history and in modern times.
You can read it here.
5/2/11 Catholic
Schools Week was a great chance to try some new initiatives - a greater
variety of prayers at assembly, greater use of sacred space. One of the
prayer services provided in the official resource booklet called for the
Taizé chant O Lord Hear My Prayer to be played/sung. By
coincidence or otherwise someone had just sent me a 3-CD collection "The
Best Taizé Album in the World...Ever". I wasn't expecting
to use it so soon! The album features 50 Taizé chants and I'm sure
I'll get great use out of it in school. I'll review it soon. I wasn't
so sure how it would fare out with the students, but some of the first
and second year students I tried it with left the prayer room singing
Jesus Remember Me!
The resource booklet also featured many other musical suggestions, and
also in one of the "Thoughts For the Day" featured a quote from
an Emily Dickinson poem I Never Saw a Moor - "I never spoke
with God,/ Nor visited in heaven;/ Yet certain am I of the spot/ As if
the chart were given".
Well, it
was about time. Finally, a national Christian radio station for Ireland!
With the country's religious demographic it's a wonder it didn't happen
long ago, but that's a long story. Spirit Radio launched last week
and here's hoping it will be a roaring success. I dipped in and out of
it plenty of times in the last week, but my comments are tentative, as
I didn't hear absolutely every programme. First impressions were favourable
- not only plenty of Christian music, but positive and uplifting secular
music as well (U2, Tom Baxter and David Gray for example). The "positive"
message is very strong, with frequent slogans and reminders - "passion
for life", "Ireland's positive sound", "positive encouraging music". Yes
we do need strong doses of positivity, but maybe this could be toned down
just a tad when the station becomes more established. More effective are
the short spiritual reflections that play every now and then. My favourite
show so far was Acoustic Sundays - an evening show with Ronan Johnston
(RoJo) which features contemporary acoustic music for discerning listeners
(like me!). Johnston's weekday morning show sounds promising too. Last
Monday when I tuned in there was a discussion, with Brother Kevin Crowley
among others, about the Capuchin day care centre which has been receiving
lots of well-deserved publicity of late for its work with the homeless.
At the weekend Jacki Ascough presented a Saturday afternoon show where,
along with the music there were useful updates about community and faith-based
events like the last Saturday's Gospel Voices concert and Transatlantic
Sessions event (see below).
Overall the station is too pop orientated for my liking, but no doubt
it will appeal to young Christians who normally listen to Today FM or
RTE's 2FM, introducing them to a whole new range of music woefully neglected
by the mainstream stations. It would help to have the presenters being
present more often after each song to tell us who the performer is and
give some background - too often it went from song to song and it was
hard to know who you were listening to. Also, I look forward as well to
hearing more talk shows on the station - I think the mix needs to be rebalanced
more in that direction, with more varied theme-based shows rather than
relying on individuals to carry long programmes on their own. But it's
early days yet, and so far so good. For the moment the station is only
broadcasting through the traditional airwaves in the main cities, but
it can also be heard live on the station's website (www.spiritradio.ie)
, on internet radios, via an iPhone app and the Nokia phone Internet Radio
app. So far Spirit is treading the interdenominational line quite astutely
- followers of the Christian religions in Ireland should find nothing
to offend and much to inspire, and long may that last.
15/1/11 Hamlet Act III Sc i: In the famous "To be or not to
be " soloiloque Hamlet reflects on our attitudes to the sufferings
of life - we can put up with them ("suffer the slings and arrows
of outrageous fortune") or fight them ("take arms against a
sea of troubles"). Suffering people opt away from self-destruction
because of the "dread of something after death", perhaps judgement
and punishment for that sin. (Clip on left features Mel Gibson as Hamlet)
Shortly after
he vents his anger on Ophelia. "Get thee to a nunnery" he tells
her, lest she be "a breeder of sinners". Those running nunneries
might not be too pleased at his characterisation of their establishments.
Hamlet's jaundiced view of women is expressed viciously to Ophelia and
stems from what he feels as his betrayal by her (she has spurned him on
the insistence of her father Polonius) and by his mother Gertrude (who
had an affair with his Uncle Claudius, whom she married after the murder
of her husband by the same Claudius). His harsh words to her seem to be
directed at women in general - "God hath given you one face and you
make yourselves another ... you jig, you amble and you lisp, and nickname
God's creatures".
12/1/11 Hamlet Act II Sc ii: In his discussion with Rosencrantz and
Guildenstern Hamlet shows a high opinion of human nature, seeing it perhaps
as God's work, and suggesting the idea of people being made in God's image:
"What a piece of work is a man! how noble in reason! how infinite
in faculties! in form and moving how express and admirable! in action
how like an angel! in apprehension how like a god!" And yet, in the
next breath man is the "quintessence of dust" - a hint of what
we learn about ourselves on Ash Wednesday. Towards the end of the scene
(clip on left, featuring David Tennant as Hamlet) the troubling issue
of revenge comes up again. Hamlet thinks he is "Prompted to my revenge
by heaven and hell". Earlier Hamlet had followed Christian teaching
in relation to suicide, but now seems to regard revenge as his duty. Again
he wonders if this ghost has been sent to fool him, though this may be
another ploy of his, perhaps subconsciously, to avoid doing what he feels
is his duty - "The spirit that I have seen may be the devil".
He also realises that sometimes evil can present itself as something pleasant
and attractive - "the devil hath power to assume a pleasing shape".
11/1/11 Back
to Hamlet now in English class, on the revision trail, so I thought
I'd better get back to my study of the religious themes in Hamlet.
Didn't make much progress at last attempt.
Act I Sc iv sees Hamlet meeting the ghost of his dead father. Hamlet is
aware of the need for spiritual protection ("Angels and ministers
of grace defend us"), in case this apparition is a "goblin damn'd".
He follows it against the advice of his friends - he knows it can't harm
his immortal soul: "for my soul, what can it do to that, Being a
thing immortal as itself?".
Act I Sc v:
The ghost, Hamlet Senior, seems to be in Purgatory (described with traditional
imagery, making up for his sins) - "confin'd to fast in fires, Till
the foul crimes done in my days of nature Are burnt and purg'd away".
He's not allowed to tell what it's like there, but hints that it's most
unpleasant: "I could a tale unfold whose lightest word Would harrow
up thy soul, freeze thy young blood, ". It seems close to the Catholic
teaching on Purgatory, yet he is allowed to walk the earth at night, and
urge his son to get revenge for him ("Revenge his foul and most unnatural
murder "), hardly a very Catholic or Christian idea. He is understandably
aggrieved that being murdered he didn't get a chance to repent of his
sins and be prepared for judgement: "Unhous'led, disappointed, unanel'd,
No reckoning made, but sent to my account With all my imperfections on
my head". Towards the end Hamlet seems to warn Horatio to allow for
the spiritual aspects of life: "There are more things in heaven and
earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy".
To be continued...
Cute
date or what! Just had to write something today. Have been using my Three
Wise Men resources (see below) this week with varying degrees of success.
Belatedly I added one more resource that has proved popular with students
- Will Vinton's claymation of the song We Three Kings, featuring
the coolest camels ever. See clip on left. The first year students in
particular were clued into the themes as some had played the wise men
in their school nativity plays.
6/1/11
On the feast of the Epiphany .... I've been putting together some resources,
old and new, on the Three Wise Men. I usually get some classes
out of this theme in the first week back after Christmas, though first
day back is usualy closer to the 6th than it is this year. I've organised
a short playlist, featuring two versions of the song We Three Kings.
The Roches version is rather tongue-in-cheek but I like it. John Michael
Talbot's version is beautiful and more conventional. Then there's T.S.
Eliot reading the Journey of the Magi. I've added these and more,
including video clips to a special new Wise Men
Page so you can play them from there. I've also added links to relevant
poems stories and images.
28/12/10 I was looking forward to BBC's Christmas drama The Nativity,
but a little nervous as well - in the wrong hands it could go pear shaped.
First off it was great that BBC put such resources into creating a new
Christmas drama on the nativity events without which Christmas is meaningless.
Tony Jordan's script was respectful of the original story, mainly from
Luke and Matthew, and there was little revisionism or iconoclasm.
As might be expected nowadays the approach was naturalistic - Gabriel
(played by John Lynch) appeared as just a normal guy, no flapping wings,
though he did come and go rather mysteriously. He visited Mary to bring
her the striking news that changed everything, and made a low-key visit
to the shepherds - no angels sweetly singing o'er the plain. The star
of Bethlehem was a distinctive planetary alignment that produced a great
light over the town, but fortunately there was no ambiguity on the virgin
birth.
The core of the story was the touching relationship between Mary and Joseph
and this was done quite well. As Mary, I thought Tatiana Maslany hit all
the right notes - she was holy, young, vulnerable, loving and very human.
Joseph, played by Andrew Buchan, was young, sincere, witty and physically
awkward. Mary was described as "such a devout girl", and Joseph admired
her purity, but at one stage when he got just a tad familiar she reminded
him of this - there was no rush, they would have their whole lives. Joseph
accepted, but passed a comment about chastity rules being made up by elders
with ugly wives! His reaction to Mary's pregnancy was more negative than
we normally see and he didn't come to accept Mary's version of events
until the birth, even after his dream. The journey to Bethlehem for the
census was particularly frosty between them. I thought the moment of insight,
moving as it was, was delayed too long.
Running parallel to the main plot line were the stories of the three wise
men and a representative shepherd, Thomas, who struggled to pay his taxes
and look after his wife and child. He was drifting away from God and driven
to attack a Roman soldier, but his faith was restored when he visited
the Messiah. Much was made of the Magi and their quest for the new king.
However they visited Bethlehem on the night of the birth, and without
paying their respects to Herod, who is portrayed as an insecure and feverish
psycho - the most repulsive portrayal I've seen, by Vincent Regan (no
relation!).
The journey motif was well portrayed - Mary and Joseph journeyed to Bethlehem
from the north as the Magi travelled from the east. There was one striking
scene with the white camels galloping through the night. The final nativity
scene, as the key characters converged on the stable, was portrayed in
a very traditional way and was quite moving.
Normally
when I go back to school after the holidays I do some work on the three
wise men, and I'll probably use some clips from this production. For school
use there are also some useful clips for teaching about the idea of the
Messiah, especially when Herod is talking about the concept. The portrayal
of Mary and Joseph's courtship might strike a chord with young people,
though I'm not so sure about Joseph's dig, however tongue-in-cheek, at
the idea of chastity before marriage.
18/12/10 Have
been doing a few Advent Services in our school's prayer room in
the last few days, a useful antidote to the Christmas tests. I have plenty
of Advent/Christmas music that I like using but I also like to introduce
some new material each year. This year I got hold of John Angotti's album
Welcome Home for Christmas - it's an excellent album, a fine mixture
of originals and tastefully done classics. Particularly useful for Advent
is his song "Prepare Ye The Way". Apart from using it for meditation
it's particularly suitable for school/youth choirs. The album is available
as a download from
iTunes
(where you can hear short song samples, but these don't do it justice
as lots of the songs have Christmas surprises built in) but even better
you can get it in Ireland from a private source - just email using the
contact link on left and I'll send the details.
I've
added a few other new Christmas albums to the collection this year.
Kimmie Rhodes' Miracles on Christmas Day is a folk/country flavoured
album featuring many original songs and a few Christmas classics. It has
a charming gentleness - I especially like "Angel Unawares" and
the the title track. It's
beautiful for home listening but I can't see myself using it in school
as I don't find that country flavoured music goes down too well. The only
song I'd have a question mark over is her cover of Patty Griffin's "Mary".
The message here seems to be that Jesus breezes off on his public mission
leaving Mary to clean up. But Jesus is described as a man "who served
the world proud" and maybe it's just a warm but ironic take on the
way sons often leave messes for their mothers to clear up!. Samples of
the songs can be heard at Amazon.
O
Night Divine is a 2008 Christmas album from US Cajun band L'Angelus
who toured Ireland last summer. The songs are mostly Christmas classics,
but given a fresh folk/roots treatment that enhances the familiar material.
I especially liked "The First Noel" which features some gorgeous
piano playing (the instrumental work on the whole album is excellent),
and I've already used "O Come O Come Emmanuel" in my Advent
services in school. Another standout track is "A Child is Born",
band member's Stephen Rees' original musical arrangement of the GK Chesteron
poem "Song of the Cradle".
8/12/10 On the topic of Christmas music: Last Wednesday morning
on the The John Murray Show (RTE Radio 1) I heard a really weird
one – Shane McGowan of the Pogues joining the Priests for “Little Drummer
Boy/Peace on Earth” (video on left) – from The Priests new Christmas album.
It certainly works as an oddity, and it’s growing on me. It helped when
the Priests appeared on the Late Late Show last Friday night on
RTE 1. They gave some background into the recording – the reservations
some had about the collaboration, how it worked so well in the studio,
how McGowan and the Priests prayed together at the end of the recording
session. The Spirit moves in very mysterious ways! Their live singing
of “O Come All Ye Faithful” in the studio, with orchestra and chorus,
was impressive – presenter Ryan Tubridy and the audience responded enthusiastically.
It wasn’t the only musical treat last week. On Thursday’s Today With
Pat Kenny (also RTE 1), American singer-songwriter Kimmie Rhodes sang
a beautiful track from her new Christmas album “Miracles on Christmas
Day”, a mixture of classics and originals, some religious. As I watched
the snow falling on my roof window she sang “silent snowflakes drifting
down”, from the song “One More White Christmas”. Ironically, her gig in
the Naul, Co. Dublin, that night was cancelled due to the snowflakes!
Meanwhile on Joe Duffy’s Spirit Level my recent wish for more music
on the show has been coming true. Last Sunday’s show finished with another
musical priest, Liam Lawton, singing the beautiful “Far Beyond” with orchestra
and choir – very uplifting. As Joe pointed out, Fr Lawton is currently
touring and promoting his new album “Courage Can Cry”.
Of course the big musical event of the media week was the semi-final of
the X-Factor on ITV and TV 3 last Saturday and Sunday nights. There
hasn’t been much spirituality evident on that show, but Rebecca Ferguson
sang a soulful “Amazing Grace” and got through to the final. She said
she had wanted to sing the song for quite a while – a song, she said,
that touched everyone who heard it. One of the judges Simon Cowell (I’m
not a fan) loved it – “no tricks … just pure sincerity” and Rebecca’s
modest and dignified demeanour confirmed that. I react to this show with
a certain fascination and repulsion. Especially at the later stages there’s
huge talent on show, not least from our own Mary Byrne, who bowed out
with dignity last Sunday night.
On Today With Pat Kenny last Monday morning the Palestrina Choir
sang “Hark The Herald Angels Sing” live in studio and accompanied by Darren
Magee, to mark RTE Radio 1’s official start to Christmas music. I’d suspect
the choir will get more applications after this outing, and it’s not their
only one this Christmas as conductor Blathnaid Murphy pointed out – lots
of concerts coming up, including a carol service in the Pro-Cathedral
where the choir is based on Sunday 19th December and a fund raiser for
Temple St hospital on Wednesday 22nd December. And if you miss those there’s
always the Christmas album “Christmas with the Palestrina Choir”.
30/11/10 Lately I've been doing my Transition Year module on Religious
Themes in Drama. You can get an idea of what I do from the "Previous
Blogs - Drama" link on left, or here.
I've many of the old reliables, but have added some new material. Covering
TV drama I was delighted to be able to use the final scene of US drama
Lost - (clip on left) where all the main characters gather in a
church to get ready to move on into the next life. When Jack meets his
decesed father in the sacristy you can see a rather unusual stained glass
window in the background - featuring the symbols of the major world religions,
though the church seems predominantly Catholic, and certainly Christian.
Even playing it in class I found it quite moving, though I've seen it
several times. It certainly held the attention of the class. In general
the clips that worked best were those from programmes the students were
familiar with, like Lost, Prison Break, The Simpsons. The
latter I used in a class on animated drama - I used a clip from the episode
where Homer and Bart become Catholic. There are some crude references
and what might by some be considered anti-Catholic prejudice, but, employing
judicious selectivity, I played a scene that includes the vision of Protestant
Heaven (very sedate, like a refined country club) and Catholic Heaven
(much more fun, including Jesus bouncing on a trampoline!). This year
I also inclded clips from The Miracle Maker (life of Jesus) which
uses cartoon and claymation. Some students were familiar with this from
Primary School, and it did hold the attention.
10/11/10 If
you like that last video here's another in a similar vein, a fine version
of Angels We Have Heard on High, also by Sixpence None the Richer.
This song and other Christmas classics are available on the band's album
"The Dawn Of Grace" (2008). Sample and/or buy the album at 7Digital.
"The Dawn Of Grace" features 8 Christmas classics and 2 original recordings!
Also includes "Silent Night" (see below) featuring Dan Haseltine from
Jars Of Clay
9/11/10 Admittedly
it's rather early to be listening to Christmas music, but I came across
this version of Silent Night by the group Sixpence None the Richer
and thought it deserved an airing. Nice animated video to go with it as
well - probably more suitable for primary than secondary school. Have
got two new Christmas albums this year so far - more of those anon. For
more Christmas music from past years click on the Christmas link in the
"Previous Blogs" section on the left.
29/10/10 Have been sampling some seriously good spiritual (and other)
music over the last week and will write it all up over the next few days.
For starters I'd like to draw attention to a new radio programme - Religion
Matters on Kildare FM (Kfm broadcasts on 97.6fm and 97.3fm ). It is
presented by Brenda Drumm on Sunday mornings 8-9 am - worth getting up
for! If you're not in the Kildare area you can listen online at http://www.kfmradio.com/
. Last Sunday morning the music was well chosen - suggestions had been
made to the busy Religion
Matters Facebook page. My favourite was Sarah McLachlan's haunting
version of the Prayer of St Francis - play clip on left. Brain
Kennedy sang Liam Lawton's Allelu, as Gaeilge, The Prayer, sung by Katherine Jenkins covered the more classical side of things, while
pieces from the Mission perfectly matched the occasion - Mission Sunday.
You can listen back to the show at http://www.kfmradio.com/kfm-podcasting.html
13/10/10 Have
been looking at the section on Signs and Symbols in the Junior
RE course. Some of the students have taken well to it - one student who
was great at coming up with suggestions for various symbols said he was
really "in the zone" on this topic. Tomorrow we'll be working
on Icons, in particular Rublev's Trinity Icon (left) - there's
good stuff on that in Orla Walsh's book Know the Way. If the internet
is working in my room tomorrow I'll be using a nice little web resource
on the icon - check it out here.
The reflections are simple, and navigation through the resource is easy
too.
3/10/10
Watched the film Raising Helenlast
night and was surprised by how positive it was towards religion and how
warm towards people and good values. Kate Hudson is excellent as Helen,
a swinging party girl who must grow up fast when she has to raise her
sister's children when the sister dies. At one stage she prays that God
will find her a good school for the children and immediately passes a
Lutheran faith school - "That was quick" she says/prays. There's
a very funny scene where she pretends to the pastor (she calls him "Father
Pastor") that they are all Lutherans. The Pastor jokes that they
will have to have a blood test to prove it, but Helen doesn't get the
irony and says the kids can have no blood tests, on medical grounds. Later,
when the pastor asks her out on a date, she feels terrible that she may
have lead him away from God and his vows of celibacy - he explains that
clerical celibacy is not an issue for Lutherans!
1/10/10 Last
Tuesday I ran a gig featuring Amy Gallatin and Stillwaters from
USA - it was bluegrass and country all the way. Amy's music wasn't too
unlike that of Emmylou Harris, and one of her best on the night was the
gospel song Satan's Jewel Crown, though it was a more uptempo version
than Emmylou's mournful version (from her classic album 'Elite Hotel').
Another fine gospel song on the night was Sailing On, written by
Rick Lang. Amy drew attention to a new album of original bluegrass gospel
songs by Lang - 'Look to the Light', featuring various artists performing
his songs. Sounds like it's worth a look.
22/9/10 In
the Pope's Mass in Glasgow last Thursday evening I was hugely impressed
with the music - from the traditional Be Thou My Vision to the
modern compositions of James Macmillan written specially for the occasion
- his new Gloria was particularly striking, and I suspect it will
re-surface in many Masses to come. Macmillan was interviewed that morning
on BBC 2 and spoke enthusiastically of his liturgical compositions (his
most famous is probably Veni Veni Emmanuel) and how Benedict's
own interest in music had been helpful to the Church. He was glad that
the people of Britain would get a chance to see the Holy Father for themselves,
as so often news about him was filtered through an often negative media.
On the Friday it was on to Westminster Abbey for a moving ecumenical service.
More original music for the occasion, this time from Gabriel Jackson -
his Glory Be to God was quite an inventive piece.
20/9/10 The
John Angotti concert in Vicar St last night was superb - musically
and even visually! To start with we got a support set from the Cabinteely
Gospel Group - high energy stuff, and how they filled the stage! Great
singing, fine musical backing. Definitely have to attend 12.30 Mass in
Cabinteely some Sunday. Quite a wide variety of material, though Oh
Happy Day might be a bit long in the tooth.
John Angotti and band were in top form, an could really cut loose in a
way that mightn't suit a church venue. It was great to see Vicar St full
on the night, great to see gospel music in the heart of a secular venue.
The sound was excellent - in school and in Westland Row Church the acoustics
weren't ideal. The patter between songs was entertaining, inspiring and
funny, but the music was all heart and soul, from the beautiful ballads
like By Name I Have Called You to the up-tempo and uplifting songs
like Common Ground and I Send You Out.
What a treat
it was to have John joined by the Cabinteely Gospel Group and the
2nd Chance Music Group for the last few songs. They lifted the roof, not
to mention the hearts of the audience. Next question: when is Angotti
and band coming back?
Nice also to meet some Faitharts friends!
18/9/10
Yesterday the John Angotti event in school
was brilliant. In the morning we had all the Transition Year students
in the town (about 110) in our sports hall for this faith and music event
and it was received very positively by the students. The music was excellent
as expected as was the participation by the students. And I got caught
when it was teacher participation time! The Deputy Principal, myself and
teachers from the girls' school rocked the joint! Apart from being great
fun it was very spiritual as well - praise, worship, reflection.
Tonight I went to the 2nd Chance Mass in Westland Row,
Dublin - John Angotti was providing the music along with the 2nd Chance
Music Group. I found it a very moving experience. I particularly loved
the unaccompanied Agnus Dei and the communion reflection song I
Can Only Imagine (video on left).As in school John was backed
by a cool band - thanks Matt, Dion and Grady! I'm looking forward to the
Vicar St gig tomorrow night.
16/9/10 Was
watching live coverage of the Pope's visit to the UK today - being
on the web it meant I could watch it in class with the students, which
worked really well. From the point of view of the arts the most appealing
aspect was the beautiful music at the Mass in Glasgow. I plan to use some
of that when I continue working on religious themes in music with my Transition
Year students.
I was hugely impressed - from the traditional Be Thou My Vision (as
commentator Sally Magnusson said, it can move all hearts) to the modern
compositions of James Macmillan, written specially for the occasion -
his Gloria was particularly striking, and I suspect it will surface
again many times in Masses to come. Macmillan was interviewed that morning
on BBC 2 and spoke enthusiastically of his liturgical compositions (his
most famous is probably Veni Veni Emmanuel) and how Benedict's
own interest in music had been helpful to the Church.
Tomorrow
we have US Catholic singer John Angotti in school for a faith and
music workshop - I'm really looking forward to that, but a little nervous
about the logistics! All TY students in town are coming to the morning
session, while our 1st and 2nd years will face the music in the afternoon.
When I do the music and faith module in TY I like to expose the students
to a live performance - this year they're in for a real treat.
8/9/10 Oh
well, back to school over a week now and exhausted. Surprised to see how
long it is since I added to the blog. Starting off again with a review of the film Karol, A Man
Who Became Pope, shown on RTE 1 last Saturday. There's lots in it
that will be useful for RE class, and the follow up film is coming up
this Saturday afternoon.
The first film takes the story from the German invasion of Poland to Karol
becoming Pope. The central performance by Piotr Adamczyk is excellent
- thoughtful, convincing, often moving. Also impressive are Malgorzata
Bella as Hanna, a possible love interest for young student Karol, and
Raoul Bova as Fr Tomasz, a young priest and close friend of Karol. Any
scenes with any one or more of these three are intense and involving.
In fact it is in some of the set piece scenes that the film excels most.
There's one that's fraught with tension as Fr Tomasz is "invited" to hear
the confession of one particularly nasty Nazi, but storms out from the
dinner table after delivering a brave rebuke to the Germans present over
their treatment of Jews and their children in particular. Great scene
for illustrating themes like injustice and prejudice. All scenes between
Karol and Hanna are so credible, a lovely portrayal of friendship and
blossoming romantic love. The tensions between them, over how to react
to the German occupation (words or guns - useful moral dilemmas here)
and his growing discovery of his vocation (see clip above), are sensitively
but realistically handled. You can feel Karol's sense of mission, but
also Hanna's sense of loss. In fact the way his vocation is handled is
so well done that the relevant scenes would be very useful for covering
the theme of vocation in class.
Scenes of the Nazi cruelty and the persecution of the Jews are strong
and affecting. It could hardly be otherwise I suppose. After the World
War 2 scenes there's much more talk as the fortunes of the Church and
Polish culture are at the mercy of the godless communism of the Russians
and their puppet rulers, but this part is affecting too, with some strong
emotional moments, especially the forgiveness of a spy - very useful scenes
for Confession and forgiveness. I thought the film was less successful
when the talk was less concerned with interpersonal issues and more concerned
with politics and theology. It's not that I'm faulting the theology, but
at times the film was a tad preachy, trying to get important points across
with lumps of theology and morality that didn't flow as easily as dialogue
should.
If you missed it, it's available for less than a fiver at amazon.co.uk,
and is available in segmented form on YouTube.
26/7/10
On Friday last I went to the Phil Murphy weekend in Carrig-on-Bannow,
Co. Wexford. L'Angelus were doing a concert of their Sacred Hymns
in the local church, and what a treat that was. Beautiful acoustic hymns
in the best of settings. They performed most of the material on their
Sacred Hymns Collection album, with some pleasant surprises like
Amazing Grace, People Get Ready and Lead Kindly Light. The
event was entertaining, inspiring and prayerful. My own contribution was
to lend the band a double bass! I think it worked well acoustically and
visually. With the band's permission I filmed the event and am including
one song, Be Thou My Vision, in this post. As time allows
I'll upload more - you'll find them on my new YouTube channel - faithartswebsite.
I've three done so far. On July 15th I had hosted a more "secular"
gig with L'Angélus in Arklow, and that was also excellent. Even
then we got treated to at least three spiritual songs. I'll be uploading
some of that material soon.
The previous
night I got to see Tom Paxton live in the National Concert Hall.
He's not particularly a gospel singer though any sixties folk singer couldn't
help but be influenced by gospel music. There was talk about heaven and
angels in his songs, especially when singing about his family. And the
opening song How Beautiful Upon the Mountain was based on Isaiah
52:7. The music and lyrics are catchy - "How beautiful upon the mountains
are the steps of those who walk in peace …. God knows the courage you
possessed, And Isaiah said it best…". We're familiar with some of those
lines in Our God Reigns. Though Paxton is at the latter end of
his career, an impressive four decades, he was like a spring lamb on the
night, full of enthusiasm and witty repartee. And he stayed on for quite
a while after the gig, signing autographs. I bought the DVD Tom Paxton
Live at Huntingdon Hall, recorded last September. Song list is pretty
much the same as on the night at the Concert Hall - the only difference
being the backup musicians. Good job I got this on the night as I can't
find a trace of it for sale on the web!
13/7/10 Hadn't
realised it was so long since I wrote here. Image, being too busy on teacher's
holidays! Anyway,
have been coming across various little spiritual gems on largely secular
albums of late so I thought I'd mention a few here over the next few
posts. Apart from personal enjoyment and inspiration many of these songs
are suitable for school use, e.g. for meditation, school folk groups,
religion and arts courses etc.
As I'm hosting a concert this week with this group (see news
page) I thought I'd start with the album Ça C'est Bon
by L'Angélus. "The Waltz of the Sorrowful Mysteries"
is a lovely French version of the Hail Mary - "Je vous salue Marie,
pleine de grace...", while "The Waltz of St Cecilia" is
a poignant song of separation and hope - "And your name on my lips
will be my morning prayer, until again we dance the Waltz of St Cecilia".
Both songs can be previewed, or/and downloaded for $0.99 at CDBaby)
There was
much to like and much to dislike about Rev. the new comedy series
that started recently on BBC 2. Practising Christians will easily relate
to the mild mannered vicar who struggles to make ends meet in an inner
city parish. His Archdeacon (on the way to the launch of atheist Christopher
Hitchens' latest book!), is breathing down his neck and mocking his puny
fund raising ideas - he needs the money to repair a vandalised window
of artistic merit. In an unlikely plot twist the congregation is swelled
by new members who are there only to gain some Christian credentials so
that their children can attend the highly rated local Church school. The
new attendees don't know whether to stand or kneel, mobile phones go off,
brats play with their games consoles, others read the newspaper in church.
There are interesting, if stereotyped, secondary characters - the inevitable
foil Nigel, the Rev's assistant who is rather stuffy, revelling in the
chance to flush out a few hypocrites, the rather underwritten vicar's
wife, and the eccentric parishioner Colin who deeply resents Richard Dawkins
for writing a book about God being deluded! Then there's the attractive
young headmistress that the Rev fancies, and regularly compliments, though
it's not clear how much he's aware of this attraction.
The show goes over the top in showing the Rev to be an ordinary guy -
he smokes, swears and sometimes drinks to excess. Unfortunately the programme
is unnecessarily crude at times, probably alienating quite a segment of
the show's natural audience, which is a pity, as the show is relatively
positive towards the Rev, and isn't negative to religion as such, but
does skewer hypocrisy, vanity, politicking, and religious pretence.
In one of the best scenes, the Rev has a little prayer to God where he
apologises for his vulgarity and reflects on his problems - I hope such
a set piece will be a regular feature.
17/6/10 Saw
the film Premonition on RTE 1 last night. Sandra Bullock played
a married woman who has premonitions of her husband's death. It was quite
a rivetting thriller with all sorts of timeshifting twists and turns.
It raised some interesting issues about love, relationships and what's
important in life. At one stage the Bullock character visits a priest
to get some guidance - it's an intersting exchange, about two thirds of
the way through. He suggests that faithless people leave a vacuum in their
lives that other forces may then occupy, and that it's important to know
what's really important in your life and to fight for that.
Further to
what I've said below about storytelling in the Bible, I came across
this interesting quote when corecting my 2nd year house exams: "God
will forgive everything unless you steal one of his apples". And
there were some creative metaphors - how about this: "purgatory is
where you get filtered for heaven". From the mouths of babes!
9/6/10 Last
Saturday evening on EWTN,
there was a fine programme with an unwieldy name - New, Sacred, Beautiful,
and Universal: Colloquium XIX. The programme featured highlights from
the 2009 Colloquium of The Church Music Association of America (CMAA),
and event which dealt with the importance and distinctive nature of sacred
music in the Catholic Church.
The spirit was infectious as we got to see and experience so many Catholics
getting enthusiastic about liturgical music. And they weren't just discussing
it - several times we got to see the rehearsal sessions, small groups
practising outdoors in beautiful gardens or by a lakeshore and the sung
masses that were the event's high points. What struck me most was the
predominance of young people - all the more interesting as the music was
mainly traditional chant and in Latin. As one of the directors pointed
out this was no bunch of oldies trying to turn the church clock back -
most weren't even around for Vatican II. In fact the philosophy of the
event seemed very much rooted in Church documents on the liturgy.
The discussions and interviews were creatively presented as well - more
like conversations as various groups of two sat down informally to talk
about church music and what it means for the liturgy. The participants
were hugely committed to the traditional sacred music in the church, especially
in Latin, and that's fine, but I think I detected, from some contributors,
something of a subtle distaste for more modern music in the vernacular,
especially if it wasn't in some sort of traditional mould. Fair enough,
there can be excesses of tacky trendiness in churches today, but I've
experienced some very respectful, beautiful and sacred music in more modern
idioms. And, it must be said, without the proper guidance and spiritual
formation, the traditional music can be become too much of a lofty performance
that excludes rather than uplifts the congregation. Whatever the case
I'm sure it must have been a wonderful experience to take part in this
event - details of the event, and the full programme under review, can
be viewed online (http://musicasacra.com/colloquium/
). Fortunately this summer there's a similar event closer to home - the
41st annual Irish Church Music Association Summer School of Church Music
takes place at St Patrick's College, Maynooth, from 5-9 July 2010 (see
News Page).
7/6/10 Holidays at last - thought those last two weeks would never end.
So, finally, a chance to catch up on a few things.
Have
just discovered a new (to me) Catholic composer and singer from America
- John Angotti. He has an excellent voice and has some impressive
material - check out the song I Can Only Imagine, in the video
clip on left. I believe a short Irish tour is planned for September -
watch this space for details. His own website is here,
and his Facebook page here.
where you can find more video clips, not just of his music, but of his
talks as well.
30/5/10 Today
is Trinity Sunday, and if wasn't such a busy time of year in school,
and if I was better organised, I'd have compiled loads of resources for
the occasion. Oh well. Have a look at that beautiful Trinity picture on
the home page, and there's a curious Trinity
video on the spoken word videos page (Jesus B.C.). My favourite
Trinity song is "Lord of Love" sung by Michael Card and Charlie
Peacock - first track on the Coram Deo album - the song can be
previewed here.
28/5/10 Had
to watch that ending of Lost again! And still very moving. (See
clip on left) And what about that beautiful background music - simple
but effective.
Interesting that in its final moment the show opted for what's a largely
religious approach. The main characters from the show gather at a church,
which apparently is some sort of Limbo or Purgatory state, before they
move on to the afterlife. One character, a man with the significant name
of Christian Shephard (!), opens the door to reveal a heavenly light,
as the characters take their seats in the church as if for a service.
The light pervades the church in a beautiful optimistic moment. These
scenes, and the earlier scenes where the characters re-unite emotionally
in this most attractive of afterlife scenarios, are intercut with scenes
of Jack dying. It's not that the characters were dead all the time on
the island (at least I don't think so) - but that they all died at various
stages on or off the island, and find each other in this "church" state
where time doesn't matter and they prepare to move on together. It seems
like a Christian church - there's a large welcoming statue of Jesus outside
and most of the imagery is Christian, even Catholic, but the ante-room
where Jack Shephard meets his deceased father features symbols and icons
from many religions - in particular there's a stained-glass window with
the symbols of the major religions - suggesting perhaps that there's room
in heaven for people of good will from all faiths. I could see myself
using this scene, as a discussion starter in RE class when dealing with
the afterlife, and it has already sparked some discussion in class. There's
also a lovely scene just before they go into the church where Ben (one
of the show's nasties, who achieves a measure of redemption) asks Locke
(one of the show's most enigmatic characters) for forgiveness and gets
it very graciously. Definitely a good one for forgiveness and reconciliation
themes.
[Added 1/6/10 - video clip of this scene now on videos
page]
I mustn't get carried away however. The show doesn't coincide neatly with
orthodox Christian thinking. There doesn't seem to a consistent purification
process in this purgatory state. Some of the characters have very serious
morality deficits that aren't really sorted out (murder, promiscuity and
more), more a case of them being ignored. But I do like the way a good
character like Hurley can find the residual goodness in Sayid, who is
very down about the evil he has done. The most obvious omission in this
afterlife scenario is God, unless we are to take "Christian Shephard"
as some sort of God figure as well as being Jack's father, or unless we
are to take Hurley as some sort of rotund Jesus figure. Maybe one could
assume that the next phase in this death experience is to meet God, and
I suppose it's not surprising that the programme makers didn't get too
explicit about such a meeting.
Looking at reaction on the web it's evident that many fans were disappointed
at the ending, but I don't share that. Some complain that all the questions
were not answered, but isn't that ambiguity what gives the show its appeal?
One of the most puzzling things for me was what to make of the alternate
life scenarios we've been getting for the characters throughout this 6th
series. It was a clever move for the script writers who haven't been content
to sit on their laurels. In early seasons we got to see lots of flashbacks,
telling us about the character's backstories. Then, in a startling move,
it was flashforwards to how some of the characters got on when they managed
to leave the island. Later we had time-shifting. Finally in series 6 we
saw the characters having alternative lives - where they all met and interacted,
but in different ways (impossible for the casual viewer to follow!). Gradually
however this seemed to be a façade, one that in some way the characters
created as a way of finding each other again (as Christian Shephard implies)
and one that crumbled away as characters remembered their island lives
- sometimes remembering how they died, and realising, with remarkable
calmness and serenity that they were dead. But even in death there was
solidarity, the bonds of friendship surviving death and becoming even
stronger. That "church" reunion scene resonates with what we'd all aspire
to - meeting those we love as we move into the afterlife.
24/5/10
Well, I'm reeling. Just after watching the final
episode ever of US drama series Lost, and what a finish! Just a
few initial reactions here. I'll return with a more detailed analysis.
It was one of the most hotly anticipated finales for years - even deserving
of a schedule change from Sky and RTE 2 to bring it more in line with
the American showing. It even got a mention on today's Morning Ireland
on RTE Radio 1. Over its six impressive seasons it has had many religious
themes. In this final double episode there was plenty of that - a very
prominent role for a character called Christian Shephard, a statue of
Jesus very prominent, a reference to Moses' burning bush, an answered
prayer to escape the island, and a final, emotionally charged gathering
in a church, one that seemed Christian and yet had symbols of many faiths,
and seemed to border on heaven!
There were moving themes of faith, hope, love, sacrifice, forgiveness
and redemption, and most of all some credence to the afterlife speculation
that has followed the show from early on. The final episode exemplified
what made the show such a hit - sharp scriptwriting, humour, characters
we could care about, excellent acting even in minor roles, spiritual themes,
adventure, unbearable tension and food for the brain. I think the hard-core
fans will be pleased - they/we will dissect it for quite a while to come!
15/5/10 Managed to get to the Don McClean concert in the new Grand
Canal Theatre last week. I was always a fan, but my appetite for his music
was whetted by the recent "Ar Stáitse" concert on TG4 - see
entry below for 1/5/10). In that entry I wrote about the religious themes
in American Pie, which of course he performed on the night. It
was going around in my head for days. Other songs of his also had spiritual
themes. I'd always thought Genesis (In the Beginning) was an arrogant
kind of song - "We have grown, we have captured the throne of the kingdom
God made". But hearing it live and paying more attention to the words
I'm not so sure. You could read it as a criticism of the arrogance of
people, or a tribute to our maturing - the kingdom is described as one
"God made for our winning". The song starts promisingly - "In the beginning
there was nothingness and God but waved his hand/and from the endless
void there sprang the beauty of the land", but I'm not so sure how God
or humankind comes out of this line: "man was but a molecule that God
had left behind". The Adam and Eve story is retold in a traditional fashion,
but a warning, that sounds like a reference to original sin, is sounded
("though the father sets the price, the children pay the cost"). That
warning is echoed in the chorus ("our children alone/have so little time
left for beginning.") That might seem to support the idea that we are
being criticised for not developing a kind of world that's helpful to
our children. Jerusalem used that city as symbol of unity between
faiths, though the ideas were more simplistic than is usual for McLean
- "The markets and the alleys, the temples and the tombs. A place for
all believers, it has so many rooms."
Apart from his own songs McLean performed a respectful version of an old
Rev Gary Davis spiritual Keys to the kingdom, - "I've got the keys
to the kingdom,/The world can't do me no harm",. He captured the righteous
anger in Bob Dylan's Masters of War : "For threatening my baby/Unborn
and unnamed/You ain't worth the blood/That runs in your veins." And includes
a Biblical flavour - "Like Judas of old/You lie and deceive". But there's
an understandable forgiveness deficit - "even Jesus would never/Forgive
what you do". Homeless Brother (see clip above) is one of my favourite
McLean songs - full of compassion for the homeless, and Jesus gets a mention
here too - "Somewhere the dogs are barking and the children seem to know/That
Jesus on the highway was a lost hobo". One could argue with that description
but no doubt it is respectful and sincere. I've been listening to the
"Homeless Brother" album of late after many years. That features
a version of Crying the Chapel (remember the Elvis version?). I
used to think that was an irreverent send up of tacky and sentimental
religious songs, but now I'm not so sure. Now I find more heart in it.
In general the concert was enjoyable but while the new venue is impressive
I thought the sound could have been better. And while it was good to hear
such a wide range of songs, I was puzzled that there was nothing from
his new album "Addicted to Black". Though it was on sale in
the foyer it wasn't even mentioned. Hardly a vote of confidence from the
artist! The backing group was musically proficient, but somehow I felt
that a certain spark was missing.
2/5/10 Recently
I was trying to think of musical resources for the theme of forgiveness
and reconciliation and came up with a few ideas. Would love to hear
more from anybody. Many of the songs are available on YouTube, iTunes,
7Digital etc. Some could probably be streamed live in class through the
likes of Lastfm or Spotify, though I haven't tried these in class yet.
Sometimes having done the Sacrament of Reconciliation I use these songs
in a prayer service or just at the end of class. Healing of the soul in
general features in the calming song Healer of My Soul by John
Michael Talbot. It's on his "Signatures" album and on the album
"Brother to Brother" where Talbot duets with Michael Card. Only
in God, also on the "Signatures" album implies reconciliation
with God - "Only in God is my soul at rest". Where Do I Go, sung
by Ashley Cleveland and Gary Chapman on the excellent "Songs From
the Loft" album covers similar ground. Tell It All Brother
is a little known song recorded by Kenny Rogers when he did music with
an edge with the First Edition group (before the awful Lucille!)
- mightn't be to everybody's taste but great for the confession theme
(listen to the song above). Under the Rug (video clip on left) by RandyStonehill uses
the title metaphor to convey the way we sweep our sins under the rug instead
of dealing with them. In Paradise by Sal Solo (saw him giving a
great concert in Rathmines church a few years ago) tells the story of
the reconciliation of the good thief on the cross. It's on Solo's album
"Look at Christ", which is hard to find, but well worth tracking
down - it's a light rock version of the Rosary, though it wasn't marketed
as such, I presume to appeal more widely than just a Catholic audience.
1/5/10 Last week American singer-songwriter Don McLean featured
in TG4's Ar Stáitse - a great new series featuring well-known performers
in concerts from the seventies. These are films which have been gathering
dust in the RTE archives and have been cleaned up for the series. What
a nostalgia trip! The McLean concert showed up the main fault with the
series - the episodes are too short! Here we had what was probably a two-hour
concert whittled down to less than thirty minutes - we didn't see him
play the banjo he brought on stage and the ending of his best known song,
American Pie, was cut off by the continuity announcer! Grouching
aside the music was great - McLean was at his best when singing beautifully
crafted songs of human interaction - we got only two of them in this show,
the yearningly optimistic If We Try ("something yearns within to
grow beyond infatuation"), and the poignant Empty Chairs ("although
you said you'd go/Until you did I never thought you would"). There were
some good-time songs like Lovesick Blues and the inevitable American
Pie - it would take quite a while to decipher all the imagery in that
one, and I'm sure thousands of words have been written trying just that.
And there's plenty of religious imagery, not surprising for a guy that
got a Catholic education, though it's not easy to detect the faith perspective.
"Do you have faith in God above?" sounds like the renewal of Baptismal
promises, but almost immediately the songwriter takes a different line
and asks "Can music save your mortal soul?" It seems as if music becomes
a kind of religion to the dedicated fans - "I went down to the sacred
store/Where I'd heard the music years before". Yet there's also the suggestion
that even God was sad when early rock singer Buddy Holly died - "the three
men I admire most:/The father, son, and the holy ghost,/They caught the
last train for the coast/The day the music died." (Three men?).
25/4/10 Recently I've been doing classes on Images of God with
2nd years - see below. To finish this topic we had a prayer service where
some of the songs I played (on CD!) reflected this theme - quite a few
interesting images of God in music and I got to thinking of some songs
I didn't use as well. So here's a few that might help - some suitable
for class work, some for prayer services and some for both. I use the
music of John Michael Talbot frequently. On the "City of God"
album he covers Carey Landry's song Abba Father, and on "Table
of Plenty" he sings Michael Joncas' well know Eagles Wings.
His "Signatures" album contains many of his best known works.
In Only in God (Psalm 62) God is "my stronghold, my saviour" (see
clip on left). In Come Worship the Lord there's the traditional
image of God as shepherd. (No doubt there'll be no trouble finding recordings
of the more traditional The Lord is My Shepherd). The image in
I Am the Bread of Life is also suitable for classes on Eucharist.
Included is the image of God as "Healer of my Soul" in the lovely
song of the same name, also featured in the "Brother to Brother"
album - duets with Talbot and Michael Card. Michael Card's solo album
"Starkindler" has a combination of images in the song The
King of Love My Shepherd Is, which also features on the excellent
L'Angelus album "Sacred Hymns Collection". Card joins with Charlie
Peacock for Lord of Love (from the album "Coram Deo - In the
Presence of God". It's an effective image for God, and a great song
for reflecting on the Trinity. For something more quirky try Julie Miller's
My Psychiatrist from the "Meet Julie Miller album" -
God as the psychiatrist whose "therapy is free of charge"! Or Larry Norman's
UFO - God as an "unidentified flying object" who's come to save
your soul! It's on his album "In Another Land", and covered
by Geoff Moore and the Distance on the tribute album "One Way - The
Songs of Larry Norman". Samples of the songs can often be found on
the artists' websites, or downloaded from sites like iTunes and 7Digital.
18/4/10 Over the last few days I've been using the German film Sophie
Scholl - The Final Days with the 5th Year students and it seems to
have them riveted. I find myself deeply moved each time I see it It tells
the true story of a young German student who defied the Nazis during World
War II - she was part of the White Rose group. She is such a great role
model for young people, and the film is superbly done - in particular
Julia Jentsch is outstanding in the title role. There's one especially
good sequence, about two thirds of the way through - Sophie says a prayer
in her cell and this is followed by her final interrogation, which in
particular raises issues of conscience and principle. It's also useful
for classes on the relationship between morality and the law. Most of
this is in the above clip which I've made larger than usual so that the
subtitles are legible.
6/4/10
Fr Liam Lawton presented an excellent Good Friday
programme on RTE Radio 1. A Love Beyond All Telling was an hour-long
reflection on the events of the first Good Friday - simply but effectively
capturing the mood of the day. Some of the spoken reflections came from
Fr Lawton's recent book The Hope Prayer, and sought to help us
understand these events at an emotional level - there were touching meditations
on guilt, heartbreak and betrayal. Yet there was hope - e.g. how radical
Jesus was even in his death - forgiving those who had crucified him. The
words were complemented by appropriate music, including some of Lawton's
own compositions, and included also work by John Michael Talbot and Matt
Maher. You can listen to the programme by clicking this
link.
29/3/10 Last Friday to celebrate the school holidays I got to the cinema
to see The Blind Side - the film that won a Best Actress award
this year for Sandra Bullock. It tells the true story of a black teenager,
uniquely skilled at American football, adopted into a white family. It
was moving, uplifting and absorbing, though overlong and certainly sentimental.
There's a faith dimension, but it's not too preachy. Bullock does a great
job playing the mother of the adoptive family, a gutsy Christian woman
who opens her home to the homeless boy, who is enrolled into a private
Christian college. When the authorities there are reluctant, considering
the boy's background, one character suggests that the word "Christian"
on the school's sign should be painted over or taken seriously. A challenge
to all our Christian schools.
Themes of racism and family conflict are touched on subtly, but there
are no huge conflicts. This makes the film less intense, but more gentle,
and it's certainly imbued with a respect and love for its characters -
at the end we get to see footage of the real life characters the film
is based on.
This family is certainly well off (huge house!), and while their material
wealth isn't questioned there is an empathy for those who are poorer,
e.g. in Bullock's visit to the boy's birth mother.
Maybe I'd like it to have been a little rougher around the edges. Is the
family too sweet to be wholesome? Perhaps, but it was good for a change
not to have the family members having clichéd rows just for dramatic
effect. It was certainly believable.
Picture this:
an obviously repentant man, on the verge of execution, goes to Confession
seeking absolution for his sins. A scruffy priest refuses, telling the
man he hasn't time to repent and that the devil awaits him in hell, and
then walks off taking the man's Bible with him!
So it was in the latest top-notch episode of Lost, the cult drama
series on RTE 2 (Thursdays) and Sky One (Tuesdays). And it gives me another
worthy addition to my collection of Confession scenes from TV and movie
drama! (this episode is due on Sky One this Tuesday 30/3)
This scene, set in 1867, was part of the backstory of Richard Alpert,
the character who never seems to age. After accidentally killing a man
he is taken in chains to the new world only to crash land (in a ship!)
on the Lost island. Gripping as that was, far more interesting
were his encounters with the island's two main protagonists - Jacob and
a nameless man in black that I'll call Black Smoke Guy (BSG) - he turns
into a black smoke creature to wreak destruction.
I've written here before about Lost being a kind of Purgatory experience
(here), but in the flashback Richard believed
BSG that the island was Hell and that Jacob was the Devil, who had stolen
his humanity and trapped him on the island. Richard believed this for
years and assured the modern-day crash survivors that they were all dead
and in Hell. But Jacob seemed more likely to be the good guy - he explained
how the island was like a cork in a bottle, keeping evil (BSG) imprisoned.
He brought people to the island to find "candidates", people worthy to
replace him, and to help people learn right from wrong on their own -
he says it's meaningless if he has to step in and force them. BSG, he
claimed, thinks people are corruptible and likely to sin by their very
nature. It's an intriguing stand off with cosmic implications, and the
philosophical implications are as complicated as the mind twisting plot
developments.
Are these two meant to be God and Devil slugging it out? It's hard to
see it in purely Christian terms - e.g. Richard asks Jacob if he can absolve
his sins, but Jacob says he can't so he's hardly meant to be God. The
show certainly makes more demands on people's brains that the average
drama series, yet it doesn't lack a strong emotional content - there was
one particularly touching scene last week when Richard's deceased wife
from 1867 paid him a visit in the present.
22/3/10 I've been doing the "Images of God" theme with 2nd
Year students - always a popular section of the course. Getting them to
draw God produces some interesting questions as usual. There were a few
blank pages and lots of bearded old men! Doing Images of God on film we
looked at the scene in Bruce Almighty where Bruce meets God for
the first time. This is mentioned specifically in the book we're using
(Know the Way) and despite it's being a few years old now many
students recognise it. I also used clips from some of the old "Insight"
videos Veritas used to sell - God as a young man in a white suit in The
Walls Came Tumbling Down, God as an office clerk in Packy, God
as Trinity in Jesus B.C. (see clip on left - some silliness, but
the only film I know that makes a stab at showing the Trinity in this
way). There's a very stereotyped God in the movie Almost an Angel -
in a scene near the start the main character (Paul Hogan) meets a
probation officer God played by Charlton Heston - robe, big beard, judgemental
but grudgingly forgiving. Not the best image of God, but it raises interesting
discussions about stereotypes and pre-conceived notions.
18/3/10 Haven't had time to do much blogging recently - too much schoolwork,
corrections etc, and I've been giving a few IT courses to RE teachers.
Have managed to listen to plenty of music in the car however, and one
CD I've been enjoying is Songs of Inspiration by Father Marino Nguekam.
Some of you may have seen him on Joe Duffy's Spirit Level a few
weeks ago, or heard him on Liveline before Christmas. I've reviewed
the album here. It's available from the Pro-Cathedral.
The video clip on left should give a good idea of Father Marino's distinctive
style.
28/2/10
On Thursday light I found my way to Colfer's pub in Carrig-on-Bannow,
Co. Wexford for a gig by American Cajun band L'Angélus. I first
came across the band when they appeared on Today With Pat Kenny
last summer and when they played for Catholic Underground during that
first Irish visit. I enjoyed their Sacred Hymns Collection (see
review here), and wasn't disappointed hearing
the live for the first time.
This was vibrant, high-energy stuff from Katie, Paige and Stephen Rees
- I've rarely seen a concert where the performers were enjoying themselves
so much. It was mostly the "secular" material - Cajun two-steps and waltzes,
country songs, Texas Swing, New Orleans Jazz and a touch of soul, but
they also gave a beautiful rendition of Be Thou My Vision, from
the "Sacred Hymns" album.
The original material, like the poignant Waltz of St Cecilia, was
mixed with standards like Jambalaya, Peggy Sue and My Girl,
and relatively unfamiliar songs like Wait a Minute (see video clip).
I always like to get more at a live gig than just a performance of CD
album material, and it was a great delight to see how much fun there was
in this performance - Stephen Rees in particular was a howl, moving from
sensitive ballads to growling shouting blues. His fiddle and sax playing
was superb, while Paige's bass playing and Katie's rhythm guitar dove
the music along, completing the excellent vocals. I was great to get to
talk to the trio during the break and hopefully they will get back to
Ireland this summer.
On the night I bought their album "Ca C'est Bon", and will give
it a mention here after a few turns in the CD player.
26/2/10
On Monday last I got to see the Irish Premier of the film Lourdes,
shown as part of the Jameson Dublin International Film Festival. It tells
the story of a young woman, almost paralysed with MS, who visits Lourdes
with a pilgrimage group, helped by Order of Malta volunteers. It's a hard one to review as I have conflicted feelings
about it. It certainly held the attention throughout its ninety or so
minutes, even though for much of it there was nothing dramatic going on.
I found it completely unpredictable, which helped, and I suppose because
it was subtitled I had to concentrate all the more. The characters were
ordinary, but still interesting. Sylvie Testud as the main character Christine
was superb - the whole thing might have collapsed without such an intriguing
performance. She managed to capture a whole range of emotions - sadness,
anger, enthusiasm, loneliness - and yet there were times she was inscrutable.
The location work at Lourdes captured the atmosphere really well, in fact
at times it had a documentary feel to it. But it was difficult to figure
out what the viewpoint of the film was. Yes there were possible miracles,
lots of prayer and devotion, and the main character, despite her suffering
was at least open to faith. But ultimately it seemed like an agnostic's
view of the Lourdes experience (and here I'm not making any assumptions
about writer-director Jessica Haussner, except that she's highly talented).
I felt the film lacked warmth towards faith, and I didn't feel any sense
of relationship with Our Lady or Jesus. It's as if Haussner was saying:
here's what might happen on an average pilgrimage to Lourdes - what do
you make of it?
And yet it wasn't entirely objective or dispassionate. There was a quiet
empathy with the invalids, especially as so many little cruelties were
shown to them - e.g. when Cécile, the chief nurse announces that there
will be an outing next day, but that those in wheelchairs would have to
stay behind. The carers do their job, often with a smile, but too often
they are more interested in flirting with each other - believable but
unsettling. "We are not here to have fun", says the irritating chief nurse,
and sure enough there is little enough of it. Everything is just a bit
too slow moving and uninspiring.
The pilgrimage chaplain is a very average priest, mostly OK with the pilgrims,
but his answers to their deep questions smack too much of platitude. The
other pilgrims are a mixed bunch, from devotional to cynical. The chief
nurse is all smiles and efficiency, not too likeable, but then she is
shown to have her own suffering. The chief Order of Malta man attracts
the eyes of all the ladies, including the main character, but he too,
ultimately, seems hollow.
Talking to some people after the film confirmed what I suspected, that
people will have wildly different assessments of the film. Maybe this
lack of a clear stance will charm some and disconcert others, but while
I did find it riveting, sometimes funny, and even quite hopeful at times,
I thought the final impression it left was on the bleak side.
For that reason I wouldn't be rushing to show it in school, though there
was one interesting Confession scene with the main character and the chaplain,
where she calmly confesses her anger. I like collecting Confession scenes
from film and TV drama, and this will be a worthy addition.
21/2/10 Stephen
Greydanus at Decent
Films (and movie reviewer with the National Catholic Register) is
one of my favourite film reviewers - I find myself agreeing with his assessments
more often than not. His website is an excellent resource, not just for
the treasure trove of film reviews, but for his many insightful articles
on various film and media issues. Currently he has an article
suggesting a variety of films that make for appropriate Lenten viewing.
Worth a look.
17/2/10 Last
night I got a chance to see one of the first Irish screenings of a new
feature film about the appearances of Our Lady of Fatima. The 13th Day was written and directed by Ian and Dominic
Higgins. It's great to see Catholic filmmakers turning their talents to
spiritual matters in such a creative and imaginative way. Visually the
film is a treat - it's not surprising that the Higgins brothers come from
an artistic background. Each frame of the film would make for a beautiful
still picture - mostly it's black and white, with colour being used when
Our Lady appears and Heaven touches the earth. Watching it I was reminded
of arty YouTube videos, European cinema, and even The Blair Witch Project
(visual effect not content!).
It was almost surreal in its presentation, which made it quite captivating
at times. The film seems to tell the Fatima story faithfully, framing
it by using the reminiscences of Sr Lucia as she writes her memoirs. For
me the telling of the story was somewhat episodic, always a potential
problem when filming real life events. I also felt there was too much
narration and not enough dialogue given to the actors which made it difficult
for them to really inhabit their roles. That being said the girl who played
the young Lucia, Filipa Fernandez, had a striking screen presence, crucial
when she was the central personality of the film.
One thing the filmmakers have achieved is to present this timeless story
to a modern audience in an idiom they can understand and relate to. I
didn't find it corny or preachy or sentimental, and these are also traps
that a religious film can fall into.
As always I wondered about its use in Religious Education. There would
have to be plenty of discussion afterwards, and the teacher would want
to be well informed about the background to the Fatima story. The vision
of hell and one rather scary angel make it more suitable for secondary
students. For teachers who might like to use just an extract, the scene
of the miracle of the sun is quite striking and captures the essence of
the film. At the time of writing The 13th Day is available only on Region
1 DVD (USA). More info on the film's website.
I saw the film at the Film Society of the Fraternity
of St Genesius, which meets on the 3rd Tuesday of the month. I was
glad to finally get there and meet people of like mind! Fr John Hogan,
Father-Director of the Fraternity gave an interesting opening address,
where he made some interesting comparisons with the earlier film version
The Miracle of Our Lady of Fatima (1952), made at a time when it
was popular in Hollywood to make films that were positive towards the
Catholic Church. Oh how things have changed!
15/2/10 Lost?
How many viewers still watch this US drama series that returned to RTE
last week? It started with a total recap episode which might have brought
the casual viewers up to date with the deliciously convoluted plot, but
I'd say they were re-established in a state of confusion once the season
opener got going. It didn't disappoint. Earlier seasons have had flashbacks,
flashforwards and people going backwards and forwards through time - this
season there's an even more intriguing plot device of having parallel
or alternative futures. Not much religion yet, but the Sayid character,
as he approached death reckoned he'd be going to a bad place because of
all the torturing he had done, and later he has a sort of resurrection
experience. A hidden temple was discovered on the island - seemed like
a sort of religion, but the devotees there certainly didn't have hospitality
as a core value - their first reaction to a bunch of strangers was "Shoot
them!".
These are the "Others", a mysterious group that have been on the Lost
island since the beginning. Their mystical leader Jacob was mentioned
but never seen for the first few series - making his appearance last year
all the more dramatic. One could see him as a sort of god-like or prophet
figure and perhaps his nemesis (smartly named Esau by some smart ones
on the web), the black smoke guy, is a sort of devil figure. But it would
be a headbreaker to try and fit the plot into some orthodox version of
the Christian story.
Caught an
episode of EWTN's youth magazine show Life on the Rock last weekend.
It highlighted the work of Epiphany
Studio - a Catholic-Christian US theatre group that specialises in
spiritual material. In particular we got to see clips from Lolek,
a one-man show by Jeremy Stanbary on the young adult days in the life
of John Paul II. In the studio interview Stanbary explained how he found
the world of secular theatre creating conflicts with his faith, leading
himself, along with his wife Sarah into their present work. No sign of
an Irish tour yet, but I've emailed to see if this might be a possibility
for the future. Some of their performances can be ordered on DVD from
their website's store. Clips, previews, and interviews are also available
on their YouTube
channel.
And on the same show there was an interview with Max Espinosa about the
Holywood
Acting Studio - a new studio that educates actors in their craft,
but also pays attention to their spiritual life, helping them to make
better choices in the mainstream. Signs of hope!
9/2/10
Started a module on the virtues with 5th
Year students today. Used a worksheet to start with, which helped get
the students thinking. To finish I got them to do some artwork on the
first virtue I tackled - Justice. I got some interesting specimens. Interestingly
no one went for the traditional scales of justice figure. The most striking
one was a guillotine on fire! Another had an electric chair being rejected.
I have a series of these Virtue Worksheets available on request - use
email link above.
8/2/10
Well, I did a bit for Catholic School's Week,
but it didn't help that we were in the middle of Mock Exams, with no school
assemblies as a result. Still, we did make use of our Prayer Room for
some class services and conducted some classes on the theme. Apart from
the discussions, I got students doing some artwork - e.g. posters to highlight
the event, which got them thinking, I hope. At the prayer services I used
the folllowing songs: Where To Now Edmund from the album "Islands
of the Heart" by Peter Kearney - it's about the vision of Edmund
Rice (it's a CBS); Be Thou My Vision by Cajun Group L'Angelus from
their excellent "Sacred Hymns Collection"; and the very appropriate
Salt and Light Amy Delaine from the compilation album "Songs
From the Loft" (a must for every RE Dept!).
1/2/10
This week is Catholic Schools Week in Ireland.
The resource materials have been sent to schools but are also available
here.
The secondary schools booklet includes a poem St Brigid, A Blessing
by Christy Kenneally. I tried it in a few classes today and it went well
I think. For the feast of the Presentation tomorrow T.S. Eliot's Song
for Simeon might be useful , but probably too complex to use as
a prayer. In the resource materials there are also prayers, readings,
full services, fun activities and even recipes! Would be interested in
hearing from anyone trying some interesting activities this week.
27/1/10 Recently I noted the passing of Mary Travers of Peter, Paul and
Mary, (see entry for 27/9/09) and now another great female singer has
died. Kate McGarrigle, along with her sister Anna wrote and sang
some wonderful songs, with the sweetest harmonies, like Heart Like
a Wheel, Heartbeats Accelerating and Love Over and Over. Their
best work I think was in their earlier 70's and 80's albums, especially
their first, simply titled "Kate and Anna McGarrigle". That
has to be one of my favourite albums of all time. I've seen them live
a few times, which was such a treat. Little of their output was religious
material, but their Catholic French Canadian background shone through
at times. There was Travelling on for Jesus from that first album,
and the many Christmas songs from their album "The McGarrigle Christmas
Hour". The latter includes her song about the Three Wise Men - I've
included a video of her singing it on the left. It's not the best recording
and she wasn't that well at the time, but it's recent and worth a look.
Rest in Peace.
16/1/10
As outlined below I've been using an extract from Jesus of
Nazareth to illustrate classes on the moral teaching of Jesus.
Part of that extract has come in handy when I've been doing "table-fellowship"
with second year students. There's a useful segment where Jesus goes for
a meal to Matthew's house (Luke 5:27-39). Matthew being a hated tax collector
the apostles try to convince him not to go - danger of scandal and defilement!
In the Prodigal Son story Jesus tells towards the end of the extract another
meal figures - the feast thrown for the returning son. When I've asked
to students to name events in the life of Jesus that centre around meals
many suggested the Last Supper, which was reassuring. I showed the Last
Supper scene from BBC's Passion, which I've referred to here many
times before. You can see it in the clip on left - Last Supper begins
about 3 minutes in, but the lead in is interesting too. I also used the
Last Supper scene from The Manchester Passion, another BBC production
that presented a modern version of the story with contemporary music.
This held the students' attention, though I found that it worked better
with older classes. I'm enjoying the table-fellowship theme from the Junior
Cert course - meals, eating, feasts figure rather prominently in the Bible
stories, whether Jesus is eating with people or telling stories about
eating - e.g. comparing the Kingdom to a feast.
13/1/10
With
5th Year students I've been doing the moral teachings of Jesus
- I usually start by showing what I think is a powerful extract from Jesus
of Nazareth - from where Jesus meets Peter on the shores of lake Galilee
to where Peter and Matthew reconcile after Jesus tells the Prodigal Son
story - about 20 minutes or so. There's so much in this for the moral
teaching topic. You have the apostle John wanting scripture to come alive
in people's hearts; there's the scene of the miraculous catch of fish
(beautifully portrayed) which emphasises the value of generosity; there's
trust - Peter has to trust Jesus and head out again even after catching
nothing so far; hospitality is highlighted when Peter invites Jesus to
his house (along with quite a crowd!), and when Matthew welcomes Jesus
into his house; the concepts of invitation and challenge are strong in
Jesus' efforts to get Peter and Matthew together; there's a powerful lesson
in reconciliation and forgiveness when they do put aside their differences,
which they must do if the are to follow the Lord; forgiveness of sins
is an issue when Jesus cures the crippled man who is let in through Peter's
roof ; the apostles try to argue Jesus out of visiting the despised tax
collector Matthew, but Jesus stresses that the heart of the law is mercy,
and that he has come to call sinners, not the virtuous. This extract has
always held the attention of the senior boys, and did again this time,
but one thing I noticed this time was the giggles when Jesus is shown
with a heavenly expression or aura - this just happens briefly at the
start of the extract, but most the time the portrayal of Robert Powell
in the role of Jesus is very moving and naturalistic - Powell holds the
viewer as Jesus holds the listeners in the telling of the Prodigal Son
story - all the more affecting as we can see the parallel with the reconciliation
of Matthew (the prodigal) and Peter (the grouchy older brother). You can
watch the start of the extract here,
and the telling of the Prodigal Son story here.
5/1/09 With
constant repeats on RTE and Channel 4 one can get overdosed on the Simpsons,
but to be fair it takes a lot of repeating to drain the humour out of
it. Last weekend both channels showed The Simpsons Movie, and like
a lot of comedy shows transferring to the big screen it was a questionable
exercise - yes, the movie was funny, but it didn't offer much more than
a typical bunch of episodes shown back to back. As always there was an
amount of religious content - and while you might welcome films that show
religion as a common part of life (airbrushed out of most American shows)
you'd smart at the sharp barbs thrown at believers. The story began on
a Sunday morning with Homer once again grumbling about going to church
- why, he says, can't he be allowed worship God in his own way - "like
praying like hell on my death bed". He grouches about Rev Lovejoy's congregation,
"pious morons" with their "phoney baloney God". Grandpa Simpson starts
speaking in tongues about some apocalyptic event, and wouldn't you know,
it was to be an environmental disaster. The show often pokes fun at those
believers who are big into "the end times". There was one hilarious scene
when the end of the world was nigh (yet again) - the believers abandoned
the church and headed for the bar, while the drinkers rushed out of the
bar and made for the church. The sign on the church said "We Told You
So"!
While Ned Flanders was presented, as usual, as a Holy Joe, he is also
portrayed as the most human and caring of the Springfield folks - providing
such a stable father figure that Bart wants him as father instead, but
only for a while of course. Yes, its mildly crude and borderline irreverent,
but its definitely funny, and even thought provoking. And suitably for
the time that's in it, it gave an outing to the idea of "epiphany" - Homer
must get a deep insight into his selfishness or he won't be able to save
Springfield and win his family back. And was there every any doubt about
the outcome?
30/12/09
Got to have another look at the film Millions on DVD last
night. It's a film by Danny Boyle of Slumdog Millionaire fame and
features a young boy who's a moral anchor for those close to him who compromise
so easily. He tries so hard to be good, and is fascinated by the stories
of the saints, many of whom appear to him, complete with halos, in little
vignettes through the film. A big bag of money, the proceeds of a train
robbery, comes his way - he thinks it's a gift from God and wants to use
it responsibly, but finds it so hard just to give it to the poor. It's
a sweet film, but not overly sentimental, and it's imbued with a warm
attitude to religious faith. The scenes with the saints are particularly
clever and amusing. It's not for very young children as there is some
menace, complex moral issues and a one-night stand (with possibilities
for the future!) between the widowed father and a charity worker.
28/12/09
At last some blogging time during the holidays. A few ideas from before
Christmas first: sometimes I get frustrated with the way RE classes tend
to get dumped on for matches, visiting speakers etc, but I've tried of
late to see it as a blessing. Admittedly it can be a break from tough
senior RE classes, but when there's only a few students left in the class
it can be turned to advantage. Once recently I was asked by a student
if he could use the time to write a song. I agreed if it could be a spiritual
song! I keep a guitar in my classroom so he borrowed that and got to work
with some other students. The end product was a bit rough, but not bad
I suppose for 40 minutes. On other such occasions I let students read
from my modest library of religious books and papers. I was pleasantly
surprised when one senior student got into a Joan of Arc story and actually
borrowed it to finish at home. In these situations the class dynamic changes
and there is more opportunity for discussion, with individuals or groups.
23/12/09 I've been catching up on the US drama series Heroes via
the box sets -I find it a strange way to watch a series. When it was first
broadcast I didn't think I'd be interested as I'm not that much into superhero
stories. But this time the characters are not super heroes in costumes,
but humans with extraordinary abilities - some can read minds, some can
be invisible, some can time travel and some can even fly. Episodes start
and end with philosophical reflections on what evolutionary or other processes
have lead to this phenomenon, and the series seems quite open to the idea
of God. Themes of choice and personal responsibility abound as some characters
use their powers for good, some for evil. And there is political resonance
for today - in the third series, for example, shadowy government forces
start to discard civil liberties and round up the ones with special powers
- in one scene, as they are hauled off to some unknown destination chained
and hooded in their orange jumpsuits, there's an obvious suggestion of
rendition flights and Guantanamo Bay. A few days ago in school I was doing
classes on the 10 Commandments and when I came to the 8th and 9th there
was the usual difficulty in explaining the meaning of "covet".
I was able to refer to one of the villains in Heroes (Sylar) who
admits that he covets the special abilities of other gifted/cursed ones
- and goes to murderous lengths to get these powers. One of students maintained
that this greed for abilities is one of Sylar's powers/abilities/curses
which raised the issue of choice - how much control does he have or is
this lethal coveting something he can't help? In some episodes he tried
to be one of the good guys but it didn't last, and in one of the posssible
futures shown Sylar is seen as a reformed family man!
11/12/09 Recently I got to see the Irish premiere of a multi-award winning
documentary The Human Experience. Can documentaries be regarded
as art? Whatever the case, this film was well put together, and it should
prove a great resource for teachers doing classes on the search for meaning.
Unfortunately it is not available on DVD yet. It tells the story of two
young American brothers, Cliff and Jeff Azize, who are searching for meaning
in their lives. They live with the homeless in their native New York,
visit a care centre for disabled children in Lima, Peru, and visit a leper
colony in Ghana, Africa. I thought the Peru segment was the best - the
children were so positive, considering their situation. One of the things
I liked about the film was the way they let the people they visited speak
for themselves. Also, the fact that it is segmented makes it particularly
classroom friendly. There is a parallel story running through the film
- one of the brothers reflects on his own upbringing and has many issues
to confront - this culminates in an emotional reunion with his father.
There are many thought provoking quotes interspersed through the film,
which again should help in the classroom context. It's a film I'd like
to see again to make a fuller judgement. Some of the film makers were
present at the screening which was a treat. I asked about the DVD release
but was told it would be a while yet as they were working on distribution
arrangements. For the moment check out the film's website,
and watch the trailer above.
8/12/09
Blogging has had to take a back seat for the last while, what with Christmas
Exams and other pressing deadlines. I've also been having fun giving ICT
courses for Religious Education Support - good to meet many Faitharts
subscribers at these sessions. Two left to go - Navan Education Centre
this Thurs 10 Dec, and Co Wexford Education Centre in Enniscorthy on Tues
15th Dec, both 7 to 9.30 pm. If interested ring Angela at Co Wexford Education
Centre.
I love this
time of year for the music. I've been using Christmas songs at
Advent Prayer Services as usual. My article (here)
on Advent and Christmas Resources gives an idea of the material I'm using.
This year also some of my third year students are doing the journal title
on special times of the year, concentrating on Christmas, so today we
had a class on Christmas music, with clips of various songs, including
ones they suggested themselves. I had most of them on CD or tape, but
the 7Digital music
download site is good for finding some clips (free) or whole songs (cheap!).
One request was for Mistletoe and Wine - not one of my favourites!
But they knew it well and even joined in the singing.
There are
some interesting new Christmas albums out this year (see recent additions
to the news page). Strangest of all must be Bob Dylan's Christmas in
the Heart - I've been listening to some of preview clips on CD
Universe and it's certainly an acquired taste! Christmas with gravel!
I've noticed that some performers are not inclined to mention Christmas
in their album titles - e.g. Sting's new album If on a Winter's Night,
Midwinter Graces by Tori Amos and Song For a Winter's Night
by Tommy Fleming all these, especially the latter, feature many Christmas
songs and carols, so is this political correctness, a chance to include
a wider range of songs or an attempt to reach a broader market?
21/11/09 Have just been watching this morning's live coverage on EWTN
of Pope Benedict's meeting with artists in the Sistine Chapel.
Loads of food for thought there and I suppose, I hope, in a way it's a
validation of the work of Faitharts and similar ventures!
The event was flagged as the first of many efforts to rekindle the relationship
between religion and artists, surely a worthy and even urgent ambition.
Around 300 artists from various disciplines gathered in this most appropriate
of venues and when they weren't watching the Pope they were staring at
the ceiling - not a bad idea when you're in the Sistine Chapel. It wasn't
just the visual art that was on show - the chapel choir sang some of Palestrina's
work at the beginning and end of the event, though we didn't see much
of them as they were tucked away in the loft! It was the 10th anniversary
of Pope John Paul II's Letter
to Artists and the event started with a reading of that letter by
an Italian film director, followed by an introduction from Archbishop
Gianfranco Ravasi, President of the Pontifical Council for Culture, who
spoke of the desire to renew the special relationship between religion
and the arts. As we travelled a path of beauty and light the arts could
open souls to the eternal. Pope Benedict himself was also inspiring in
his address. But he was also realistic - accepting that some of those
present might be remote from the practice of religion. Yet his language
was the language of friendship, dialogue and collaboration. He stressed
that the world needs beauty if it's not to fall into despair, and that
the artists were the custodians of beauty. He was also conscious that
there were problems, that there could sometimes be an escape into mere
aestheticism, there could be the guise of indecency, and gratuitous gratification.
But the pursuit of authentic beauty wouldn't go down those roads, in fact
it could even wound us, which I found a rather striking idea, but makes
sense if you think of a pained reaction to the depiction of suffering
in a film for example, and indeed you wouldn't have to go much further
that the Sistine Chapel art works to find examples of that. Finally, against
the amazing backdrop of Michelangelo's Last Judgement he called
on the artists to be aware of their responsibilities and grateful for
their gifts as their God-given talents glorified the Creator and challenged
them to be heralds of hope for humanity. As soon as I find video of the
event and the text of the address I'll post the links, but it should be
up on YouTube soon at www.youtube.com/vatican
[video added above 22/11/09, full text of address here
]
16/11/09
Today in school we had a retreat with the Net
Ministries team, most of whom are young Canadians visiting Ireland.
We used the local parish centre and students thought it was helpful to
get out of the school for the day. The team was excellent - dedicated,
courteous and professional. I was glad to see them using plenty of arts
resources - they sang, involved the students in the singing, and used
short dramas to illustrate their points. I joined the team and students
for a prayer service in the local church, which was a special experience
for me too. One of the team sang at the prayer service, while there was
some beautiful reflective music during the time for individual prayer
(I hope to draw attention to some of this music when I can track it down
- it was a compilation from various sources). I have rarely seen my senior
students so quiet, reflective and focussed!
3/11/09 I
know it's unseasonal, but last week I got to attend the multimedia screening
of A Christmas Carol - this is Robert Zemeckis' new film adaptation
of the Dickens story for Disney, and what a treat it is! Those who have
seen his Polar Express will be familiar with the kind of animation
applied here - a technique of motion capture that has the characters looking
incredibly like the actors that do their voices. The effect here is immeasurably
heightened by the eye-popping 3D effects. And it's not just the occasional
gimmicky scare with something being flung at the audience - the 3D effects
are seamlessly integrated throughout and you'd wonder how you could ever
bear to watch it in 2D cinema or DVD. You seem to fly through the air
with the characters, it seems to be snowing in the cinema, and yes, occasionally
a few things appear to fly into the audience, the most delightfully disgusting
being Jacob Marley's ghostly spittle as he tries to warn Scrooge about
the consequences of leading a selfish life. The amount of detail is incredible
- we see textured wrinkles and spotty skin, which doesn't sound very appealing
but in the context it's brilliant.
The technical wizardry is jaw-droppingly impressive, but without a good
story it would ultimately leave an empty feeling. Of course, Dickens provides
a timeless and very human story of redemption at Christmas time which
is told faithfully in this adaptation. Jim Carrey plays the central role
of Scrooge with his usual zest - he savours the role, wallows in it, hams
it up at times, and yet, despite many laughs it is a very serious story
and we get to feel all of Scrooge's changing emotions. Yet, for some reason
it fell that little bit short at the emotional level, perhaps because
of the fact that the characters are animated no matter how realistic the
detail. I felt this particularly to be the case when Scrooge is given
a glimpse of the sweetheart of his youth, estranged by his over concern
with money. The emotional resonance should, I thought, have been much
stronger here. One of my favourite previous versions was the Muppet
Christmas Carol and amidst all the crazy Muppets, the real Michael
Caine did a better job at capturing the humanity of Scrooge. The film doesn't hedge on either the frightening or the religious
elements of the story - if anything they are heightened. Smaller children
may get a legacy of nightmares from the death coach that chases Scrooge,
or the horrors of the graveyard scene where the ghost of Christmas come
lets Scrooge see what a miserable future and death he will have if he
continues with his self-centred behaviour. After a series of horrors he
finds himself dangling over a yawning grave, with his open coffin waiting
for him, and under that a hellish red glow. Then there's the horrific
appearance (video clip on left) of the ghost of Scrooge's deceased partner
Jacob Marley - he seems to have come from hell or more likely purgatory
carrying the chains he has made for himself in life (reminded me of the
first appearance of the ghost in Hamlet). And as he leaves we get
a scary vision, worthy of Dante, of many other troubled souls, tortured
by the choices they have made in life.
But it's primarily a story of redemption and salvation and so the other
religious elements are more positive, apart from a dig at "men of the
cloth" who seem responsible for Sunday closure of a place where the poor
can cook their food (reminded me of those who criticised Christ for healing
on the Sabbath). There was liberal use of traditional Christmas hymns
on the soundtrack. Sometimes it's just a hint, (Ave Maria), sometimes
more prominent (Hark the Herald Angels Sing) and sometimes quite
central (Adeste Fideles). On the end credits there's a new song,
where Adrea Bocelli takes up Tiny Tim's "God Bless us Everyone".
Christmas Carol is due in cinemas on Nov 6th - go see it! For more info
and trailers see the official
website.
27/10/09
On holidays at last, and I get to catch up on Hamlet. Act I
Scene iii features the departure of Laertes for France. He warns his
sister Ophelia to mind her honour with Hamlet, but she's a sharp one,
reminding him to practice what he preaches, giving Shakespeare a chance
to get in a dig at hypocritical clergy who don't follow their own teaching.
Ah the timelessness of it!
" ... But, good my brother
Do not, as some ungracious pastors do,
Show me the steep and thorny way to heaven,
Whilst, like a puff'd and reckless libertine,
Himself the primrose path of dalliance treads"
I have found that saying farewell to family members going on long journeys
is a special but sometimes painful experience. Laertes recognises how
much of a blessing it can be, especially as he gets a chance for a second
farewell:
"A double blessing is a double grace;
Occasion smiles upon a second leave".
Towards the
end of the half-term, the first year student (see entry
for 30/9) who promised to sing U2's Yahweh finally came up
trumps. He did well considering that the student who was going to sing
with him couldn't find the lyrics! I'm really taken aback by how much
of an impact this song has made in this particular 1st Year class - they
still request it! I must incorporate more music into this class.
18/10/09
Finally I get to Hamlet. As I'm doing this with a 5th
Year English I thought I'd reflect on the religious references that abound
in the play. When he sees a ghost (Hamlet's father) in Act I Scene i Horatio,
Hamlet's friend, on seeing a ghost declares "Before my God, I might not
this believe /Without the sensible and true avouch /Of mine own eyes."
- this reminded me of the apostle Thomas not believing in Christ's resurrection
until he could feel the wounds. The ghost disappears when the cock grows
for dawn leading Marcellus to say that there's a legend that approaching
Christmas the cock crows all night long so that ghosts can't appear at
all, even at night: "Some say that ever, 'gainst that season comes/Wherein
our Saviour's birth is celebrated, /The bird of dawning singeth all night
long; /And then, they say, no spirit dare stir abroad". In Scene ii Hamlet
is heartbroken that his father is dead and his mother remarried to his
uncle Claudius. He won't however commit suicide as it's against God's
law: "O … that the Everlasting had not fix'd /His canon 'gainst self-slaughter!"
Needless to say Hamlet is shocked to hear that his father's ghost is appearing,
and reckons it's a sign that evil has been afoot, but will be revealed:
"Foul deeds will rise, /Though all the earth o'erwhelm them, to men's
eyes". To be continued ....
13/10/09 At the moment I'm covering the Junior Cert Course material that
deals with the events of the last few days in the life of Jesus.
Apart from doing the scripture readings and seeing what the text has to
say, I use video clips to illustrate the events. For the Last Supper I
used the relevant clip from BBC's Passion (written by the late
Frank Deasy), with Joseph Mawle as Jesus. I love the way they do the scene,
and it ties in with the later Resurrection sequence where the disciples
on the road to Emmaus recognise him in the breaking of bread. For the
other scenes I use Jesus of Nazareth clips which haven't dated
that much and still hold the students' attention quite well. The trial
before the Sanhedrin can be viewed in the clip on left.
12/10/09
Have been covering the Sacrament of Reconciliation during the week,
and among the resources I've used have been clips from various dramas
that feature Confession scenes I've gathered over the years. Best of all
is the scene from The Mission (about quarter way in) where the
priest played by Jeremy Irons visits the slave trader played by Robert
de Niro who is consumed by guilt after killing his brother in a fight
over a woman. The priest challenges him to set his own penance - and there
follows a painful trip up the mountains carrying a bundle of his armour
that scene also is great for symbolism of guilt and forgiveness. I also
use a clip from Ken Loach's film Raining Stones - near the end
a man confesses an unintentional killing to a priest, played with dignity
by Tom Hickey (anyone remember Benjy from The Riordans?). It's
very intense and the emotions are raw but genuine. There's one F-Word
in the scene, but in the context I think it's acceptable in a senior class,
considering how effective the scene is. Argue with me if I'm wrong! There's
a scene in Hamlet (click here
to read it and hear an audio file) where the murderous King Claudius tries
to repent of his sins but can't because he's not prepared to give up what
he has stolen. Kenneth Brannagh, in his film version sets this scene in
a Confession box, which heightens the whole repentance theme. The scene
ends in the vision of a bloody stabbing (not in Shakespeare!) so I usually
cut it just before then. A Confession scene from the old US drama series
Nothing Sacred features a usually "trendy liberal" priest giving
a hard time to a young student who has got his girlfriend pregnant. One
student found the priest too heavy handed, but the young man probably
needed a tough reality check. While these scenes teach a lot about the
sacrament, I also use two clips that are more for focussing attention
- one from the X-Files where Scully seeks advice more than reconciliation
in the Confession box, and a similar one from Prison Break where
Michael Scofield is having moral quandaries about the way he is letting
the ends justify the means, and is having difficulty letting go of his
guilt, not quite willing to sin no more. There's certainly something about
a Confession box that lends itself to intense drama!
4/10/09
It's rather unseasonal I know, but I've being doing
Patrick Kavanagh's poemAdvent
with a 5th year English class. Sometimes I think I teach more religion
in English class. I introduce Advent as a sort of mini-Lent, a time of
fasting before the feasting of Christmas. Thus we have the "dry black
bread" and the "sugarless tea", symbols of the self-denial that can make
us spiritually fit for Christmas (hinted at in imagery like "stables where
time begins"). And there is a reward - the recovery of innocence and freshness.
Kavanagh makes the need for repentance clear: "We have tested and tasted
too much". There is a sense that the poet has overindulged, has become
satiated with experience, like a person who feels uncomfortably bloated
after too much food or fizzy drink, and so needs to cut back. But Kavanagh
is concerned more with inner well-being: "penance will charm back the
luxury of a child's soul". And then there will be a change of perspective,
once again he will be able to see things as he did when he was a child,
he will rediscover "the newness that was in a every stale thing", for
example "the spirit-shocking/ Wonder in a black slanting Ulster hill".
Towards the end of the poem Kavanagh opts for an experiential approach
to religion, rather than one that is too analytical/intellectual (Artists
1 - Theologians 0). He wants to experience God and His creation with the
heart rather than the head: "we shall not ask for reason's payment … Nor
analyse God's breath in common statement". Ironically he rejects another
kind of experience - that of sin). He might seem to have a thing against
knowledge, but he seems to be reacting against his own over indulgence,
negative experiences, knowledge of sin: "The knowledge we stole but could
not use". It's not too much of a jump to see a link with the forbidden
fruit of the tree of knowledge in the Garden of Eden. Now the "wages"
of sin are to be "thrown into the dust-bin" so that Kavanagh can move
spiritually refreshed into Christmas and the new year: "Christ comes with
a January flower".
I
got to use clips from Kings (see below) in class at last! I'm doing
the theme of forgiveness and reconciliation with 6th year students
and two clips were useful - one from The New King 1 where King
Silas forces his son Jack into a humiliating apology. "Forgiveness
is an act of love, and I don't love you" he says, imperiously, much
to the annoyance of his wife, and follows it with a crude remark. It's
unsettling stuff but fitted right in with what we had been discussing
in class. In this case neither the apology nor the forgiveness were genuine,
but in the next clip, from The New King 2 Rev Samuels makes a heartfelt
apology to God for his sins - a model of genuine repentance.
1/10/09 Kings Episode 12 - The New King 2: And so it ends. This episode
sees the end of the series and it won't be back - it was cancelled in
the USA when it didn't get enough audience support. It was obvious from
the finale that certain plot threads were opened up for the second series
that was originally envisaged. There are some interesting comments from
the show's creator Michael Green (also involved as a producer on Heroes)
on the Kings
website.
On the religious angles here's what he had to say: "The network had no
negative reaction at any stage to religious content within the show. In
fact, they encouraged it and found it hopeful…. It was only when time
came to market the show that a decision was made not to promote the show
as a biblically inspired tale. Fear of reprisal from the religious audience
was the described cause. Something NBC has had bad experiences with before.
As such, any references to 'King David' were actively avoided, in favor
of the limited marketing campaign that many of you saw and have commented
on with derision … There was no "religious agenda" among the writers.
The writing staff was deliberately comprised of a diverse group of geniuses.
Including believers and non-believers, lapsed and actives, people who
are atheist, Jewish, Christian, Muslim. All had done their homework. All
their perspectives were invaluable…. Most religious viewers actually quite
liked the show. Understanding that our creative task was not transcription".
And what a finale! (see highlights in video clip above) It was high-tension
stuff all the way as the political and personal conflict between King
Silas and his son Jack came to a head. Rev Samuels pays the price for
being involved in the plot against Silas - but before that he has an excellent
scene of repentance - a heartfelt prayer to God. I'll certainly use that
in RE class when I'm doing the topic of repentance. Samuel's remorse is
certainly genuine, and it's a powerhouse performance by Eamonn Walker
in the role. And his character has a really interesting role to play towards
the end of the episode. Samuels wouldn't give his blessing or benediction
to the crowning of Jack as King and so fell out of favour with the arch
conspirator, Silas' brother-in-law. We got the incongruous scene of a
civil servant reading out a pre-prepared blessing instead - saying something
about church-state relations perhaps, or about how some states and some
politicians can use the trappings of religion to suit their own very secular
purposes.
The presence of God is felt strongly in this episode - at one stage Silas
begs God for a sign, challenging Him to knock over a whiskey glass! God
appears to oblige, but Silas wasn't looking. Later in a knockout scene
reminiscent of King Lear, we see Silas in a thunderstorm, talking to God,
and apparently being told by God that David is the chosen one to take
over the kingdom (no spoiler to those who know their Old Testament David!)
- this has been pretty obvious all along, but David hasn't seen it - has
just doggedly persisted in his duty to be loyal to the King. He now knows
of Silas' evildoing but helps him back to the throne because the plotters
are worse and planning war when Silas favoured peace. Silas is not pleased
at this news from God, and while at first he seems grudgingly resigned,
he declares himself an enemy of God and plans to stop David who must escape
into exile.
I hope these reviews have been of interest. After going back to school
and having less time I sometimes regretted committing myself to reviewing
every episode, but at least the work is done now. Maybe when I get more
time I'll write a shorter article to bring all the threads together in
a more compact way.
30/9/09 Kings
Episode 11- The New King 1: It's a pity they didn't do this as a two-part
finale for the series - it would have been a heck of a conclusion. However
there was plenty in this episode to satisfy. There was one scene I could
see myself using in school with senior classes when dealing with issues
relating to forgiveness/reconciliation. King Silas makes his son Jack
go through a humiliating and grovelling apology for his actions during
the dramatic trial scene conclusion in the previous episode. Obviously
I'd see this a lesson in how NOT to do forgiveness! It would make an interesting
contrast with the prodigal son story. Without giving too much away the
romance between David and Michelle is in trouble, and no-one but Michelle
and Queen Rose knows about the baby resulting from the affair between
David and Michelle. The political machinations become even more twisted,
with David threatened with execution and an assassination plot on Silas.
The final scenes are high octane as the fates of the main characters hang
in the balance as the political intrigues reach a climax. Roll on the
final episode!
I've used U2's song Yahweh several times
from the CD (How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb), especially when
looking at religious themes in music. Then I found a beautiful acoustic
version of it (video on left) from a U2 concert in Chicago. As Bono gets
a mention in the RE book Know the Way I thought I'd play this for
some junior classes. It has been a big hit with 1st Years - after the
first playing of the clip I got plenty of requests to play it again the
next day. One student said he'd started learning it on guitar and has
promised to play it for the class soon! I never get tired of listening
to it myself, though I have mixed feelings about U2. See the lyrics of
Yahwehhere.
27/9/09 Kings Episode 10 - Javelin: As I expected this was a very
dramatic episode. The Americans do trial scenes better than anybody and
the trial of David for treason was very tense. I was reminded of the trial
of St Thomas Moore, at least as portrayed in A Man for All Seasons.
David protested his loyalty to the king even as the king was part of the
plot to get him condemned on trumped up charges. He remonstrates with
Silas saying his only offence was to keep his affair with Michelle, the
King's daughter, a secret - no sign of the affair itself being regarded
as a sin! The concluding scene was one of the most dramatic scenes in
the series so far. Again the scenes between Rev Samuels and the King are
intense and really well written - at one stage he cautions Silas that
David is becoming only what he is intended to be - presumable king at
a later stage. "Don't give God reason to tear from you this kingdom",
he also warns, suggesting his spiritual powers by causing a blackout in
the store where they meet. But Samuels has been compromised by an incident
in the past and Silas resents him taking the high moral ground now.
RIP - Mary Travers, Frank Deasy Was
very sad last week to hear of the death on Sept 16th of Mary Travers (left),
of Peter, Paul and Mary, a folk group that sang and recorded together
for five decades, producing a consistently high standard of great music.
They popularised the works of Bob Dylan, recorded some of the best civil
rights songs of the sixties and often included gospel music in their repertoire.
PP&M - traditional standards like Sinner Man, All My Trials, Tell It
On the Mountain, along with contemporary Christian music (CCM) like
Hymn and Christmas Dinner - both written by Paul (Noel Paul
Stookey) who had a solo career in CCM - he wrote The Wedding Song - There
is Love. PP&M's album A Holiday Celebration is one of my favourite
Christmas albums and I've often used tracks from it in school prayer services.
See early video of PP&M here. More tributes
and info at peterpaulandmary.com
Frank Deasy also died last week, on Sept 17th. He had been interviewed
on RTE Radio 1's Liveline early that week about organ transplants,
but unfortunately he didn't last the week. Frank was an award winning
TV scriptwriter whose work included BBC's life of Christ The Passion
from two years ago, which I reviewed in detail on the blog. His other
work included Prime Suspect and this year's Father and Son.
24/9/09 Today
I started on Patrick Kavanagh's A
Christmas Childhoodin English class. It's full of spiritual content.
The poem will ring a bell with anyone who has happy memories of Christmas
childhoods. The religious aspect of Christmas doesn't get short changed
here: there are the "Mass-going feet", the "Three Wise Kings" are brought
to mind by three "whin bushes" on the horizon, the cow-house reminds the
poet of the stable of Bethlehem: "The light of her stable-lamp was a star/And
the frost of Bethlehem made it twinkle". And in the imagination of the
child "The light between the ricks of hay and straw/Was a hole in heaven's
gable". Such use of light, common in religious poetry, also figures strongly
elsewhere in the poem - the "stars in the morning east", "the winking
glitter of a frosty dawn". Music mightn't have figured strongly in the
original Christmas story (apart from the angels singing), but it is prominent
here - from the actual music of his father who "played the melodeon",
to the metaphorical "music of milking" and the sounds from the paling-post:
"the music that came out was magical". But it's not just a poem of happy
memories - some deeper philosophical issues are touched on. There is a
sense of the sin that has taken the poet away from childhood innocence,
and there is that link with knowledge and the Garden of Eden: "O you,
Eve, were the world that tempted me/To eat the knowledge that grew in
clay/And death the germ within it". He can recover innocence, in a way,
by memory ("Now and then/I can remember something of the gay/Garden that
was childhood's") and the poem ends with a flower image suggesting innocence:
"And I had a prayer like a white rose pinned/On the Virgin Mary's blouse".
20/9/09 Back
at school a week or so now, and it's tiring! We don't have Transition
Year in our school this year so I won't be doing my religion and arts
course. However I've written extensively on this in the blogs over the
last few years. This year I'll be trying to use arts resources more consistently
in my regular religion classes, so I should have plenty to write about.
No doubt, also, I'll be coming across several religious themes in my English
teaching. Patrick Kavanagh (pictured, left) and Gerard Manley Hopkins
are on the Leaving Cert English course for the exam in 2011, as in Hamlet,
so I'll have plenty to write about there. We started with Kavanagh's poem
Shancoduff,
not one of Kavanagh's most spiritual poems by any means, but it does have
an odd Biblical reference - he says that if Lot's wife had been as "incurious"
as his "Black hills" of Shancoduff, she wouldn't have turned to a pillar
of salt! Kavanagh does tend to go for one-off exotic references.
Kings:
Episode 9: Chapter One. A very scriptural episode you might say! While
there are various interesting plot developments in this episode, the most
interesting angle is the writing of the show's equivalent of Scripture.
A scribe in the court of King Silas is writing the Book of Silas. David
has been sent on a dangerous mission, to recover the charter of Gilboa
(similar in appearance I thought to the American Declaration of Independence)
and with him out of the way Silas wants to be the hero of his own story.
David's plight is not the only example of someone being sent into dangerous
territory, perhaps with a view to his convenient demise (what King David
story does that remind you of?). However the writing of this particular
scripture takes a different turn and we end up with the writing of the
Book of David. It's fascinating and subtle. On the plot level the Queen
and King are up to their usual machinations, abusing their power in secret,
while often appearing magnanimous to the general public. There is an interesting
discussion between King Silas and David's mother about David's destiny
- a destiny that will not appeal to mother or king ("You and I will wish
it never happened", she says to him). Ian McShane continues to chew the
scenery as Silas - I'm be disappointed he's not nominated for an Emmy
Award. Silas' relationship with God continues to intrigue - in this episode
he again feels that he is not in God's favour (not surprising!) - he asks
"Why does he reject all my offerings?". The dramatic ending of this episode,
the arrest of David, promises some intense scenes to come.
13/9/09
Kings Episode 8, Pilgrimage: David joins King Silas on a "pilgrimage",
but to his surprise it's a visit to Silas' lover - it seems he is rekindling
that affair after abandoning it in some sort of deal with God (as he imagines
it) to save the son he had in this relationship. David is not so forthcoming
about his affair with the King's daughter Michelle, leading to major trust
issues. Meanwhile the Queen is desperate to keep her son Jack's gay affair
out the public eye, increasingly difficult after his lover tries to go
public and commits suicide. Quite a potboiler. Of course the Bible stories
on which all this is more than loosely based features lots of immoral
goings on, but the moral perspective was clear, whereas in Kings
the moral perspective is far from Biblical! David's affair with Michelle
is, I think, seen in a favourable light (though the deception aspect of
it threatens to cause them serious trouble), while a modern gay rights
agenda seems more and more strongly to inform the story of Jack's difficulties.
The lover who commits suicide is, to an extent, worryingly portrayed as
a hero (even by Rev Samuels who presides at the funeral and is seen by
many of the kingdom to have the voice of God), while Jack is tempted to
come out of the closet - the programme seems to take the point of view
that he should embrace his homosexuality.
31/8/09
Kings Episode 7: The Sabbath Queen. I've just started watching
the series Heroes and may write about that at a later stage, but
I notice that the creator of Kings, Michael Green, was also a producer
on that show and wrote some of the episodes (a point made in the interview
- clip on left - with Susannah Thompson who plays Queen Rose Benjamin
in Kings). Not surprising in a way, as both shows are interested
in philosophical issues.
I've started adding the programme titles to these reviews as there is
some variation in the episode numbering on various websites - depending
on whether the opening double was numbered just as episode 1, or as 1
and 2. The official
website doesn't number the episodes, and for some reason leaves out
the episode "Judgement Day".
This "Sabbath Queen" episode slowed down the pace. The city of Shiloh
is hit by a power blackout and various characters take advantage of the
darkness - Jack to resume briefly his gay love affair, David and Michelle
to have a one-night stand and an unidentified assassin to make an attempt
on the king's life - you'd think these people never got out! I was reminded
about various Biblical quotes about sin and darkness - e.g. this one from
John 3:19: "Light has come into the world, but men loved darkness instead
of light because their deeds were evil", or this from Ephesians 5: 8-13:
"Have nothing to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness, but rather expose
them. For it is shameful even to mention what the disobedient do in secret.
But everything exposed by the light becomes visible".
Apart from the assassination attempt, it wasn't clear that the one night
stands were seen as sinful - yes, they were furtive, and in the case of
David and Michelle, you'd get the impression it was going to come back
to haunt them, but you could argue that the programme was portraying these
events as good, hardly a Biblical perspective. And again they were portrayed
in a way that would make teachers hesitant in using the material in schools.
David still seems to want to do God's will, but wonders which of the voices
in his head come from God, and there was an another interesting God-thread
in is episode, conveyed mostly through flashbacks - the whole idea of
making deals with God. When Michelle was young she was at death's door,
in fact what appeared to be a personification of death arrived to take
her, but Silas bargained for her life. Ironically, so did Michelle herself,
vowing a life of service to humanity rather than to herself, if she survived.
She seems to regard this as precluding her from marriage, but curiously
not from an affair with David! Not exactly a vow of celibacy. So, which
deal, if any, saved her life? Stay tuned.
23/8/09
Gave
a plug during the summer to the band
L'Angélus who were touring in Ireland and performed at Catholic
Underground
events. After listening to them on Today With Pat Kenny on RTE Radio 1
I ordered one of their CDs, Sacred Hymns Collection, and it was
certainly worth it. There's great music on the CD that is suitable for
school use, for meditation, school choirs and folk groups. What I like
best is the fresh contemporary arrangements given to familiar hymns, especially
the beautiful version of Be Thou My Vision, which I think will
help young people discover the value and beauty of songs that have become
too familiar in uninspired arrangements. I've often thought that the old
hymns needed an uplift. Many contemporary Irish performers have reinvigiorated
old Irish folks songs, rescuing them from come-all-ye hell, but I'm still
waiting for a similar approach to our heritage of great hymns. This release
will help, as did some tracks by Van Morrison (who also recorded Be
Thou My Vision) and Beth Nielsen Chaman (on her Hymns and Prism
albums), but I'm still waiting for the definitive work! See also my review
of the album here.
Kings Episode 6: Brotherhood. Yet another shift of mood in Kings
this episode as two new plot lines develop. The city of Gilboa is struck
by a plague (very Old Testament!) and King Silas orders a curfew reminiscent
of the Passover - he even mentions a passing over and avoiding the "angel
of death", as every household is asked to put a candle in the window as
a sign of solidarity. Of course the Passover is out of sync chronologically
with the Saul/David story in the Bible which provides most of the characters
and plotlines, but the writers of Kings are not setting out to provide
an exact parallel and there are all sorts of resonances from elsewhere
in the Bible and from more modern events. In the plague story for example
Michelle annoys her mother the Queen by tending to a young boy who is
dying alone from the plague - "she can't be mother to them all", a phrase
which brought Mary, the mother of Jesus to my mind at least.
Silas blames God for the plague - He tests me beyond endurance, he complains
to Rev Samuels, who suggests the problem is something rotten within his
kingdom, a poison that needs to be purged (hints of Macbeth and Hamlet?)
Meanwhile on the political front David and the King's son Jack are on
a mission to capture a terrorist - the visual style here, as they fight
in the forests, reminded me of stories about partisans in World War II
(as in the recent film Defiance).
The relationship between David and Jack (Jonathan in the Bible) develops
- Jack resents David, seeing him as a usurper of his father's attentions,
yet he says he doesn't regard him as an enemy, in fact he can't understand
David. There are hints of the Prodigal Son story here (actor Sebastian
Stan as Jacks exudes an intense anguish of jealousy), and it's a plot
that figures strongly in films like Gladiator and Road to Perdition
- the inadequate son replaced in the affections of the leader by a newcomer,
who becomes the son and heir the leader wished his real son had been.
The relationship between Jack and David gets more intricate as each saves
the other's life during the mission, and both end up in the embrace of
King Silas, who has just seen off another challenge to his authority.
11/8/09 Kings
Episode 5: Judgement Day: One of the things I like about this programme
is the way each new episode (so far) has something distinctive - a change
of location, a change of tone, a new character or whatever, so there are
always surprises. This episode centres around Judgement Day - a special
event in the Kingdom of Gilboa when the King takes on ten cases to deliver
his own personal judgement - "divine wisdom my only counsel" he says.
Sounds a bit like Solomon, and sure enough his son Jack passes some sarcastic
comment about cutting babies in half. Petitioners make their pleas in
orange envelopes and the dramatic sight of thousands of these strewn around
the palace floors is a powerful image of dashed hopes. David is torn between
loyalty to the King and loyalty to his family as his brother Ethan goes
on trial for treason. Chris Egan as David (pictured above with Ian McShane
as Silas) portrays the pain so convincingly. Struggling with his dilemma
he says he doesn't even know if there is a God, but later in an interesting
discussion with the king feels he understands the ways of God - he sees
God working through King Silas, as he seems to accept Silas' declaration:
"I am justice".
The romantic subplot between David and Michelle the King's daughter (Michal,
daughter of Saul from the Bible) takes a few interesting twists, while
the mysterious Edward (Macaulay Culkin), the Queen's nephew, returns from
exile. The best scenes I think are those intense discussions between King
Silas and David (as at the end of this episode) and the king and Rev Samuels,
usually about faith and God's will. Some of these would be useful for
RE teaching. Unfortunately I can't say the same for an unpleasant sex
scene, fairly strong by US network TV standards, at the start of this
episode.
2/8/09
Kings Episode 4: As expected, a much more political episode this
time and quite a political thriller, with lots of tension crammed into
the 45 minutes. Lots of Holy Land suggestions with the people of Port
Prosperity rebelling against the King's decision to hand back this land
to neighbouring Gath as part of the peace process. The locals don't want
their God-given "promised land" to be handed over or divided. You couldn't
help but see parallels from Bible times to the modern Middle East. And
in the portrayal of the shipyard riots there was surely a visual reference
to the Solidarity protests in Poland.
Ian McShane continues to excel in the role of King Silas while Chris Egan
perfectly captures the pain of the innocent David - trying to be loyal
to his King and to his family in Port Prosperity. A political coup is
thwarted, the King's son Jack (presumably a parallel for Saul's son Jonathan
in the Bible) is even plotting against him. There's even a possible dig
at CNN - the TV news in the Kingdom of Gilboa is UNN, and there's interesting
talk of the news being "crafted"! Fascinating stuff, and if you weren't
aware of the Biblical connections you'd probably find it so and even more
intriguing.
30/7/09 On
last Sunday's episode of Joe Duffy's Spirit Level on RTE 1 Helen
Toner of the recent Knock Youth Festival reckoned that music was very
effective at engaging young people, and sure enough there was some quality
Christian rock on the show (a genre underexposed in the Irish media) -
from the North of Ireland there was a video of the Rend Collective Experiment
(the song was more accessible than the name!), and in the studio we got
another soulful gospel song from Padraig Rushe (pictured above) - a former
Dublin Gospel Choir singer who has a promising solo recording career -
check him out on My
Space.
It wasn't just the musical arts that figured on the programme. The recent
Icons in Transformation exhibition in Christchurch was really unusual,
and not just because the Protestant Church, according to Joe Duffy, was
traditionally suspicious of religious images. The work of Ludmilla Pawlowska
of the Eastern Orthodox Church was a combination of traditional icons
and modern works inspired by them. It was striking how much the human
eye figured prominently in the modern works, and how the colours were
just as vibrant as in the traditional counterparts, but in a very different
way.
Last Thursday Cajun group L'Angelus
played a superb live set for Today With Pat Kenny on RTE Radio
1, which included a beautiful rendition of Be Thou My Vision. While
they play many "secular" gigs their Catholic faith is important to them
and to the whole Cajun culture. In their Irish tour they have been playing
for the Catholic
Underground, an innovative group that combines prayer and the arts,
an initiative described enthusiastically on the show by Fr Sylvester of
the Friars of the Renewal in Moyross. On the strength of that show I've
just bought their album Sacred Hymns Collection and will review
it here shortly.
26/7/09
Kings: Episode 3 (Shown on RTE 2 last Thurs). Episode 3 moved at
a slower pace than usual and had a very different mood. The King's son
Jack took young David on a sleazy night out in the city, but despite Jack's
best efforts he kept his virtue (though there are photos that falsely
suggest otherwise) - he still seems smitten by the King's daughter. We
learn that the King's wife has been the architect of the kingdom and it's
royal family ("we are the performance" she says as the great and good
of Shiloh come to a ballet), a kingdom that she has moulded from when
it was just a place of warring tribes, and she'll be as manipulative as
it takes to keep it that way.
Since his alienation from God King Silas complains "My plans are frustrated",
and he returns to God and Rev Samuels for help when his love child gets
seriously ill leading to some interesting exchanges about what God wants
by way of sacrifice - he accidentally knock's over a deer and wonders
if that will do! The Biblical flavour is present, and not just in the
storyline - King Silas's love child is called Seth, in the Bible one of
Adam and Eve's sons; there's talk of David's star "shining bright"; talk
of an alternative sacrificial lamb; and when a sponsor wants to pay ten
times more for a seat beside David than for a seat beside the king, the
Queen feels the sense of threat - "David commands his 100,000, the King
commands his 10,000".
The next episode promises to be more political as resentment is brewing
over Silas giving away some Gilboan territory to seal a peace treaty with
Gath. Rev Samuels disapproves as part of the deal with God (covenant?)
seems to be "undivided lands, as promised", perhaps a suggestion of present
day issues in the Middle East as well as in Biblical times. You could
even see and Irish political reference in that, though somehow I doubt
it was intended!
20/7/09
The
only thing disappointing about Episode 2 of Kings (the Old Testament
modernisation on RTE 2 Thursday nights) was the fact that it was only
40 minutes or so in length - the pilot had obviously been a double episode.
Though settling into series mode the quality remained as high.
Plot wise, David continues to serve King Silas in the city of Shiloh,
not realising that Silas plans to have him assassinated as he considers
him a threat. David's character (sympathetically played by Christopher
Egan) is appealing - though he can be naive, he is gentle and idealistic,
and in most cases is diplomatic, always finding the right word to say
in awkward situations. The Biblical King David's interest in music is
reflected in David's interest in playing the piano. In this episode he
takes drastic action to save the peace treaty with Gath, without which
he reckons his brother's death will have been pointless. In this episode
there's a strong emphasis on a sense of destiny for David. His mother
Jesse feels this and wants him home because he thinks it will be dangerous.
Silas feels it, feels threatened and wants him dead. David himself wants
to follow the signs given to him. He gets some very strong "Don't go"
messages, including one dramatic scene where he apparently dreams that
Silas is calling out "Don't go" to God in the Heavens. His dead brother
appears with the same message, but it takes David a while to figure out
how he should apply it.
Rev Samuels doesn't figure so much this time, and Silas believes he can
manage without his benediction. The political shenanigans continue in
the kingdom as the King's brother in law tries to ruin him by withdrawing
gold from the treasury, while welcome comic relief is developed through
two of the temple guards who have to clear some birds (pigeons or possibly
doves) out of the palace. The birds have a symbolic role interfering in
the assassination plot on David in the dramatic conclusion. There is excellent
background material on Matt Page's Bible
Films Blog, while the official
website for the series features some useful material, though the clips
and full episodes are for US viewers only.
19/7/09
I watched the first episode of Kings again last night (see entry
for 12/7) and found it useful to have a second viewing. Since then
I've also done some revision on the Old Testament stories on which this
modernisation is based. I'm still positive about the show - it's visually
appealing and intelligently scripted. The Biblical parallels are fairly
clear - King Silas (a great performance from Ian McShane) is Saul, Rev
Samuels is the prophet Samuel, the kingdom of Gath (with their Goliath
tanks!) is presumably the Philistines (in the Bible Gath was one of the
royal cities of the Phillistines). Jesse is David's mother rather than
his father as in the Bible. Apart from such clear references there is
an "Old Testament flavour" permeating the show - e.g. in the names of
other characters and places - Eli (David's brother), Benjamin (the surname
of the royal family), Shiloh (King Silas' new city, and in the Bible an
important city for the people of Israel), Gilboa (Silas' kingdom in the
show, but a mountain where King Saul was killed in battle in the Bible).
You could even detect a New Testament element - in one emotional scene
when David offers his blood to Gath people in order to make peace, the
sense of self sacrifice was reminiscent of Jesus' own sacrifice. And I
was further reminded of the American political background with the reference
to "the Vineyard" - seemed to be a summer palace for the king, reminiscent
of Martha's Vineyard in USA, which had links with US politicians
including the Clintons.
Review of episode 2 to follow soon.
14/7/09 The Message
Behind the Movie by Douglas M Beaumont is a new book about "how to
engage with a film without disengaging your faith". Beaumont, who teaches
Bible and philosophy at the Southern Evangelical Seminary in North Carolina
USA, has a work that is really three books in one. At times it's a work
of Christian apologetics from a Protestant perspective (in fact the Protestant
sensibility is evident many times). I particularly liked his outline of
how reasonable it is to believe in God and can see myself using some of
that material in school. Secondly there's an ongoing piece of fiction
running through the book as some young adults talk about faith using various
films as starting points. I found this the weakest point in the book as
it's not compelling fiction, and more distracts from than illustrates
the points the author is making. The treatment of faith and films is the
core of the book, and what is said is thought provoking, though I'd like
to see a more in-depth in approach. The films used as examples are right
up to date, and it's good for a change to find a book considering the
moral implications of films, not just their artistic merit. Particularly
useful is the point that even if we consider a film harmless because it
mightn't have an adult rating, it's important also to consider the values
being imparted even if the content seems innocuous enough. The book also
has the feel of a manual, aimed perhaps at the education market - the
exposition is straightforward and there are "Reflection Questions" at
the end of each section. Further, there's a very detailed reference section
at the end which contains lots of interesting side comments.
12/7/09
Kings is a new American drama series that started on RTE
2 last Thursday night and it certainly is different. It's a modernisation
of the story of the kings in the Old Testament, with David being a central
character.
The setting seems vaguely American, present day, but the leader is a king,
King Silas. He presides over a powerful kingdom and as the story starts
dedicates the new city of Shiloh, an urban landscape not unlike New York.
He's at war with the neighbouring kingdom of Gath a conflict that provides
a background of political intrigue. Silas is convinced that he has God's
approval, symbolised by a mystical experience with butterflies, and has
been anointed to his role by the mysterious Rev Samuels. He is quite upfront
about declaring this despite the unease of his political advisors ("God
isn't popular at the moment"). However he is no paragon of virtue, not
averse to bumping off political opponents, and having a mistress on the
side despite his loving family and finally Rev Samuels tells him he has
lost God's favour and protection because he agreed to a treacherous war
at the behest of a ruthless businessman to whom he is beholden. David
appears as a David Shepherd (clever!), a country boy who has risen to
prominence in the war because he saved the king's son Jack (does every
series have to have a Jack?), and in the process knocked out a tank called
Goliath!
Earlier Rev Samuels had met him and in wiping a car oil smudge off his
face seemed to anoint him for great things in the future. By the end of
this episode David is visited by the butterflies while Silas looks on
ruefully, while the shadowy businessman is plotting to put the pliable,
grumpy and secretly gay Jack on the throne - in a modern nod to political
correctness Silas tells him that if he lives his life "as God made him"
he won't be fit for the throne. The programmer works on a least three
levels - firstly it's a reasonably good political thriller, featuring
all the usual conniving, with some of the clichés of the genre balanced
by many imaginative touches. Secondly it could be viewed as a political
allegory - a way of teasing out the political power issues of modern America
- the war scenes for example take place in a desert where the visual imagery
is suggestive of Afghanistan or Iraq. And thirdly of course there's the
obvious Biblical parallel - I watched it before I revised my Old Testament
so I could judge that it stood on its own as a good story, but these Biblical
references make it fascinating, adding that extra layer that makes it
stand out. So far I find it respectful to religion. Of course you'd squirm
at the idea of a modern despot (even if he's benign at times) claiming
divine approval, but Rev Samuels provides a moral grounding in his role
as prophet or conscience - "don't pretend I don't know" he says to Silas
on several occasions.
This show has been running for some time in the USA where it has met with
mixed fortunes - it started out in prime time but has since been bumped
to a less prominent slot, though not as bad as what RTE has done with
it - virtually ensuring obscurity by plonking it after midnight.
As regards using it in school, I'll certainly be adding clips when I do
religious themes in drama with Transition Year, but there are many useful
clips for other topics, especially those encounters with Rev Samuel -
could be useful for classes on conscience, on anointing in the sacraments,
on church-state relations, relevance of bible stories for modern times
and more.
2/7/09 I'm
surprised and delighted to see so many events/initiatives this summer
in the faith/arts area. Check out the news page
for full details, but there's the Quilty Artists, a new group for those
interested in this area, a summer conference, on the Image of God, in
Glenstal Abbey, organised by the International Society of Christian Artists,
an exhibition of Icons in Christchurch Cathedral in Dublin, a songwriting
competition for the Year of Evangelisation in Dublin diocese, and quite
a few interesting events in the National Concert Hall Dublin, including
the intriguing Rosary for Solo Piano!
Hollywood actor and Oscar winner Karl Malden died yesterday at
the age of 97. One of his most famous roles was as the priest Fr Barry
in On the Waterfront (1954). The clip on the left shows him speaking
out against mob corruption, and makes for a great classroom resource on
many topics from justice to the religion in film.
22/6/09
I went to the MAD (Make a Difference) Christian Music Festival
in Glenealy Co. Wicklow last Sunday and caught some good performances.
I didn't catch every band, but Emmaus was the best of what I did see.
Fronted by Ronan Johnston they performed some driving Christian Rock as
well as some meditative worship music. Particularly impressive were their
new version of St Patrick's breastplate (Patrick's Shield) and
the moving You Have Never Let Me Down, both on their new album
Mountaintop. Ben Cantelon and Soul Survivor, returning from last
year, were similar in style. Also returning was Shel Perris. Her material
was very dance orientated, sung to backing tracks, which wasn't my cup
of tea, but she impressed in the few slower, ballads-type, songs she performed
with her band.
Many T-Shirts proclaimed "God Loves Hip-Hop", but I found that group LZ7
way too loud and took a walk to the Mad Café tent, one of the best new
ideas this year, a new stage which featured (apart from the food) some
more low key and acoustic groups. The Revival Gospel Choir from Arklow
livened the place up big time, while groups Just Mercy and Water's Edge
produced good music without being the least bit flashy. Two members of
the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal sang a few heartfelt spiritual songs
and seemed to go down well with the audience, a majority of which was
probably non-Catholic Christian.
As a non-denominational Christian event it was quite interesting - evangelical
prayer groups in some areas (even to the side of the main stage), the
Franciscan Friars having impromptu prayers in another corner of the field,
and everybody having a great time in the sunshine. And what a great venue
- a huge flat field, plenty of room, more than adequate parking and toilet
facilities. Great place to be on the longest day!
15/6/09 The
Shack: This novel by William Paul Young has been a big hit in evangelical
circles, and while I enjoyed parts of it, I have some issues with it.
Without giving too much away, it's about Mack, a man whose daughter Missy
is kidnapped. During his trauma Mack meets God and learns a lot about
himself, about life and about God.
The earlier part of the book, including the kidnapping, is really well
written, as gripping as any thriller, with thoroughly interesting characters.
In the long middle section, where he meets God, the pace slows down dramatically,
to suit that unusual plot development, but I felt it took from the novel
as a novel. In that section it was too much like a theology book, too
much like the author rather unsubtly using the characters to drive home
his own vision of God. I like theology and I like fiction, but theology
thinly veiled as fiction I'm not too keen on.
However I did like the way God is portrayed - the imagery is striking.
God is most definitely portrayed as a Trinity. God the Father is Papa,
no surprises there, but Papa is a kindly female figure - God needs to
approach Mack this way as Mack has had unhappy experiences with his own
father. Jesus is Jesus, another kindly figure who loves Mack and accompanies
him on parts of his journey of discovery. The Holy Spirit is Sarayu, an
ethereal being, hard to pin down, hard to focus on. God is entirely loving,
forgiving and understanding, altogether a pleasantly warm presence. I
particularly liked the bit where God has hung pictures painted by humans
in the Shack - just like any loving parent would hang picture painted
by their young children.
There is an issue with a human writer putting words in God's mouth that
aren't scriptural, and any Christian writer has to proceed with caution.
God has a lot to say in this novel, and at times He's overly dismissive
of religion, and even politics, which grated. Also He's not keen on moral
rules, which I thought was naïve on the writer's part. Fair enough, some
believers can be too legalistic, and also if we are all perfect, we would
be moral without any need for rules, but we're far from perfect!
The novel falls into the trap of going for spirituality over religion,
which to me suggests of an underlying distaste for the imperfect community
of struggling and flawed believers who make up any religion.
7/6/09
Got a chance at the weekend to see a preview of
the film Sinner, a new independent film from USA. It looked promising,
but was a real disappointment. The storyline features a middle-aged priest
(Fr Romano) who had a secret love affair in the past that he feels guilty
about. He has to share a parish with a young priest (Fr Stephen) who is
conservative but in an unpleasant way (surprise, surprise) e.g. he rails
against Vatican II liberals. Eventually Fr Romano sends him away for psychiatric
evaluation! Yes, it's a bad time to be conservative! Into this mix comes
a prostitute who preys on priests - Fr Stephen hits her - to protect his
celibacy, he says. She tries to blackmail him but Fr Romano takes a more
compassionate approach, though resists her advances. Meanwhile Fr Stephen
takes pictures to build up a case against Fr Romano with the bishop. It's
a pretty hackneyed male fantasy pot-boiler as might be obvious by now,
but perhaps something good might have been made of it. However it's ruined
by poor pacing and plotting, stereotypes and most of all by many objectionable
elements - nudity, loads of foul language and many distasteful scenes.
5/6/09
Shock horror! I've just discovered I've written no blog entry for May!
A sign of how busy things were in school. I'll make up for it in June.
I've barely managed to get some new stuff and the news
page and keep the media previews updated.
Anyway, time to put things right. I've always regretted not writing down
every funny thing I've got in exams or homeworks from students. Correcting
TY exams recently a student was discussing art and religion and referred
to Michelangelo painting the "16th Chapel"! Mentioned this in
the staffroom but a history teacher had also got this in the past.
30/4/09 I've
started working on Eucharist with my 6th Year students. It's rather late
in the year I know, but I'm trying to lead into the Graduation Mass and
make it more meaningful. It's not easy to get attention at this time of
year so it's a struggle. A few days ago I used a few useful video clips
and these really did hold the attention of the students. First off I showed the Last Supper scene from BBC's Passion
- it's very down to earth and realistic but doesn't hedge on the Eucharist.
I take it from the start of the washing of feet scene (around 3mins 15
seconds into the clip on left) and on to where Jesus and the apostles
rise from the meal. Then I go to the post resurrection where Jesus meets
the disciples on the road to Emmaus - Jesus is played by a different actor,
which works really well I think, until they recognise him in the breaking
of bread - the Eucharist scene here matches the Last Supper scene and
showing the clips together effectively makes a point. For contrast I then
showeed the Last Supper scene from BBC's Manchester Passion - (you
can se the full video here
- the scene is 10 mins 30 secs into this video) - it's a modern setting,
with music, where Jesus uses a burger bun and a bottle of wine - sounds
"off" but I find it serious and respectful. The song used is
Love Will Tear Us Apart by Joy Division, which some of the students
knew and even sang along with in one class!
27/4/09
Regular readers will know I look forward to the
musical items on the show Spirit Level, the monthly religious magazine
programme on RTE 1, and once again I wasn't disappointed. There were two
soulful performers - Padraig Rushe, formerly of the Dublin Gospel Choir
sang the catchy Free Now from his new album Greyworld, while
Joseph Fitzgerald's best song was the haunting and unaccompanied "Deep".
See it all at the Spirit
Level website.
17/4/09 Recently
I finished reading an excellent novel - Danny Gospel by American
writer David Athey. It came highly recommended and I wasn't disappointed.
It's a spiritual novel, but the touch is light, and it's not doing any
heavy evangelising. Danny Gospel, the central character, has an interesting
family background - part of a family gospel singing group, but a family
that has known great tragedy. Yet the tragedy is blended with hope, and
while at times the approach seems surreal and mystical there are no pat
solutions. At times it's achingly beautiful and at times achingly painful,
as Danny searches for meaning after the events of 9/11 leave a profound
mark on him. I love books and films where the minor characters are well
developed and this is certainly the case here. I came back every night
to the book as I would to a good thriller, and have just started re-reading
it and am enjoying it all over again, and hoping to make better sense
of what mystified me first time around. It has been well received as the
reviews
on Amazon testify (and on Amazon, with the "look inside"
feature you can even read the first 12 pages), and I'd certainly recommend
it to Religious Education teachers for their own enjoyment and inspiration.
Selected passages might also be useful for senior classes doing "search
for meaning".
16/4/09 Oh
well, I'm disappointed with the way the 24 series has turned out.
I had hoped for more of a redemption theme (see previous entry) but when
the new series started one of the first things was Jack Bauer defending
his questioning techniques (i.e. torture!) to a legal hearing, and it
was the investigator who was trying to combat human rights abuses who
came across as the fussy one! In the second episode there was a corny
scene where a young policeman driving Bauer said he thought Bauer was
getting a raw deal. The only sop to a changing attitude was Bauer saying
he wanted it all out in the open, so the public he was so patriotically
protecting could judge how far they wanted him to go. The end justifies
the means in 24 land! Ironically in another scene Bauer warns against
the dangers of compromising on standards. He should take some of his own
medicine. OK, it's still riveting drama, heightened by the trademark real-time
approach, and the new female president (a Hilary Clinton look-alike) looks
like a decent sort, concerned with human rights abuses in a fictional
African country. Also, it's early days yet, or should I say early hours,
so maybe things will improve.
6/4/09 The
US drama series 24 has returned and started on RTE last Monday
night with a two hour drama special to lead into the new series. 24:
Redemption has been out on DVD for a few months, and the cover tells
us that Jack Bauer has been working as a missionary in Africa, so I was
intrigued, as Jack has been a rather ruthless anti-terrorist agent up
to now, a bit of a fascist actually, torturing prisoners, even the innocent.
As always it was a tense and riveting drama, but I felt they could have
done more with the redemption theme. If anything, redemption comes for
a friend of Jack's who is seems to be a missionary of sorts working with
disadvantaged children in a troubled African country. Jack is helping
out at the school, though whether to make up for his sins as one character
suggests, or just to hide out from the American authorities (sleazy stereotypes
as usual!) isn't too clear. The issue of child soldiers is central to
the story and Jack certainly shows courage in defending them, but I can't
help feeling that for the programme makers this is just an excuse, a plot
on which to hang some vicious fighting and blood letting. Maybe I'm too
cynical about this. I'll watch the new series for the drama and tension,
and hope that the redemption theme is continued, but I wouldn't be hopeful
that religion teachers will find much in 24 that they can use in
class. Check out a video trailer for 24: Redemption at Amazon's
page for the DVD.
Right, I
learned a lesson this week - never do a prayer servivce on April Fool's
Day! I brought a group of 1st year students to the prayer room for
service leading into Holy Week and Easter. I was all set with my music
selections and prayers, but it went pear-shaped. The students were unsettled
for April 1st, and then started acting up because allegedly there was
a spider in the room. It wasn't a pretty sight to see 1st years getting
so agitated about a spider. I assumed this was an April Fool's prank and
soldiered on with great difficulty. Later I returned on my own to the
prayer room and found the remains of a poor spider - so maybe there was
something in it. Anyway, lesson learned!
26/3/09 Have
enjoyed doing the Resurrection with my 3rd Year students. Apart
from reading the gospel accounts and doing the theological content I showed
the Resurrection scenes from Jesus of Nazareth and from BBC's Passion.
Students did well at figuring out what was left in or left out or added
for the video. On the BBC version they had no problem with the different
actors playing Jesus after the Resurrection, a novel way to get across
the idea of Mary Magdalen and the disciples on the road to Emmaus not
recognising him at first, but they weren't too keen on the way Mary Magdalen
looses the cool and starts throwing stones around when she finds the empty
tomb. Though I've seen both versions several times I still find them very
moving.
24/3/09 Last
Sunday I tuned into the second episode of RTE's new monthly religious
programme Spirit Level, and again I was quite pleased with the
content. The formula was the same - a mixture of discussion and musical
items. Not exactly an innovative format (it reminds me of BBC's now defunct
Heaven and Earth show), but hey, it's "easy like Sunday morning",
and in my book it works. I was curious to know what musical items would
feature this time - appropriately there was a less familiar than usual
Ave Maria by singing group Acabella, and at the end a song by Ronan
Keating from a new album of his mother's favourites. I'm not a Keating
fan (boy bands yuk) but he sang one of my favourite songs, Cyndi Lauper's
Time After Time so I was conflicted. It was well sung, but was
a music video, which lost the sense of immediacy and presence of a live
performance. The two shows broadcast so far can be viewed here. Still
on the artistic beat there was an item about the new film The Secret
of Kells, an animated feature about a young boy working on the famous
book. Director Tomm Moore accepted it wasn't a religious story as such,
but of course it had religious symbolism. He had set his story at a crossover
point between the old pagan ways and the new Christian way and, as he
put it, wanted to be respectful to al that was going on then. In reflective
mode he felt a bond between the original illuminators of the book and
the present day animators. Certainly judging by the clips shown it is
a beautifully animated work. Robin Adams of Trinity College Library that
is home to the Book of Kells was happy to be associated with this
project as he felt the book was treated with respect in Moore's work.
The film's website
has resources for schools, trailers and lots more. See also News
page.
16/3/09
Had my best
laugh of the week watching the world premier of a new Simpsons episode
In the Name of the Grandfather - it's a special on Sky 1 for
St Patrick's Day (7.30 pm), but I got an invite to an advance screening
today in the Lighthouse Cinema, Smithfield Dublin.
Best of all was getting to meet Nancy Cartwright (voice of Bart), James
L. Brooks, (Producer) and Al Jean, (Executive Producer). They were really
good humoured people who obviously still enjoyed their work. Getting paid
to play! There wasn't a lot of time for detailed discussion but I asked
Brooks about the way the show portrayed religion, and he said that they
just wanted to show a regular family that watches TV and goes to Church
every Sunday! With around 15 writers working on the show I didn't get
the impression that there was any party line on religion. I asked Al Jean
about the target audience - yes it was originally conceived as an adult
show, but it was obvious considering the format that children would be
drawn to it. And while they didn't aim the show directly at children,
they didn't intend to do anything "R" rated. Cartwright was really enthusiastic
about her work and obliged with a few of the funny voices. Interestingly
she lamented the lack of positive role models for young people today,
but accepted that Bart Simpson wasn't quite what she had in mind.
As for the
episode itself - of course you'd expect a rake of Irish stereotypes as
the Simpsons came to Ireland - and it would be churlish to complain. They
did it quite cleverly - having most of the Oirish clichés in Grandpa Abe
Simpson's flashback to when he spent great times on the Emerald Isle,
and so there were pints galore, dancin' in bars and cabbage on tap as
runny as the beer. So now as he returns years later (on a Derry Air plane)
all is changed as the Celtic tiger has transformed the land (this was
written last summer!) - Abe's favourite pub is empty, the owner (voiced
by Colm Meaney) can't even remember how to pronounce pub or pint, and
everywhere you look there's signs of dubious progress - we get glimpses
of the Hewlett Fitzpackard and Mick R O'Soft companies, and yupprechauns
walk the streets. As they tire of this new bland Ireland they are encouraged
to stay by a busker - yes, it was Glen Hansard from the film Once
in one of the funniest turns in the episode.
Homer and Abe revive the pub by letting people defy the smoking ban -
until they are busted by the gardai - the scriptwriters' research slipped
up here with "Police" instead of "Garda" signs. As usual there were a
few crude bits, but no religious content. When it does do religion it
can range from gentle mockery to support, but whatever the case it amazes
me how the show can keep the standard of writing so fresh and funny for
twenty years and around 450 episodes.
13/3/09
Today I was
covering the theme of search for meaning in modern culture with
a 2nd year class - I normally do this kind of thing with senior classes,
so I wondered how I'd fare out. We looked at examples from music today
and will look at film and TV next week. One resource I found useful in
class was the music download site 7Digital
- as I was referring to search for meaning, especially spiritual meaning,
in the songs of the likes of Bruce Springsteen, Van Morrison, Bob Dylan
etc. I was able to play clips of these songs using the preview facility
on the site. Actually, necessity was the mother of invention as I'd forgotten
my CDs! One student suggested Heal the World by Michael Jackson,
but unfortunately I couldn't find it. Found it later though by first checking
which of his albums it came from (Dangerous). I've found 7Digital a great
resource for finding individual songs for class. They only cost around
99 cent, and many come in MP3 format with no digital rights restrictions,
so they should be easy to burn to CD or transfer to memory stick for classroom
use. I've rarely searched for a track in vain, and the sites includes
a huge range of gospel/spiritual/religious music. You can pay per song
rather than having to pay a subscription per month as with some download
sites.
11/3/09
Have started on my module about religious themes in poetry with Transition
Year students. Fortunately the course poems for Leaving Cert 2011 are
available so I'm able to include the incentive that these poems relate
directly to their Leaving Cert course. Kavanagh and Hopkins are on for
that year so I'm spoiled for choice - started with three Kavanagh poems
- Advent,
Canal
Bank WalkandA
Christmas Childhood. It was hard to get the students' enthusiasm
going, but their discussion of the poems was perceptive. Hopkins next
week! That'll be an even greater challenge.
6/3/09
Have
just come across a beautiful Stations of the Cross presentation
online that could be used in class as part of the preparation for Holy
Week. Stained glass artist Richard King produced this work which is available
as an online slideshow - the pictures move on rather quickly so you may
want to use the pause button. The original work is in Swinford Church.
See it here.
Writer
Christopher Nolan figured in religion texts in the 80's. Nolan
had to write with his mother's help using a "unicorn stick"
on a word processor, a witness to human dignity showing great creativity
despite his disability. Unfortunately Nolan died recently. I came across
a nice tribute to him from fellow blogger Raymond Arroya. Check it out
here.
Yesterday I wrote about my Religious Themes in Drama module
in Transition Year. I used many of the same resources as last year (check
out the drama archive - link on left). One new resource I used when doing
the section on animated drama was Give Up Yer Aul Sins - animated
versions on Dublin youngsters from the 60's telling gospel stories. It
went down really well with my students (15 year old boys). Fortunately
this is now readily available on YouTube. The one I used, about the death
of Jesus is the video on left.
5/3/09
Yesterday in school we had our annual visit from
the Covenant Players, a group of travelling Christian actors. This was
part of the Religious Themes in Drama module in Transition Year.
Once again it went well - apart from some interesting and entertaining
plays the actors involved the students in various drama exercises.
On other fronts I'm doing the last days of Jesus as part
of the 3rd Year exam course - we read the different scriptural versions
and then after each segment I show the relevant clip from Jesus of
Nazareth for the most part. I used the Last Supper scene from the
BBC Passion, with Joseph Mawle as Jesus. When I get to the Resurrection
I'll use that again as it presents it in an unusual way - with two other
actors playing Jesus - to convey how Mary Magdalen and the disciples on
the road to Emmaus didn't recognise him. For the arrest, trial and passion
of Jesus the Robert Powell portrayal in Jesus of Nazareth is fine.It's
interesting to see how the different gospel accounts are blended. The
clip on left is of the questioning of Jesus before the Sanhedrin and also
Peter's denial.
Have
just finished doing the Sacrament of the Sick with 6th years. Among
the resources I used were Hopkins' poem Felix
Randal which shows in a very personal way the priest administering
the last sacrament. I also played the song Now is the Time for Tears
by Charlie Peacock from the excellent Coram Deo album - this is
based on Job, and imagines a bereaved person asking his friends to grieve
with him rather than try to fix him. Had also planned to play John Michael
Talbot's beautiful Healer of My Soul but ran out of time.
28/2/09 The
80th anniversary of the Vatican state was celebrated recently. First I
heard of this was on Salt
and Light TV on the web (well worth a look), on their Zoom
programme of news updates. There was a special Vatican concert featuring
The Messiah performed by the RTE Concert Orchestra and Our Lady's Choral
Society from Dublin. Pope Benedict attended and spoke of the value of
music in announcing Christ, because it makes mystery perceptible with
an eloquence completely its own. RTE's news coverage of the event can
be found here.
British Poet Laureate Andrew Motion also made an interesting comment recently:
"People cannot expect to understand much of literature - from John Milton
to TS Eliot - without learning the Bible first".
25/2/09 Last Sunday morning saw a new religious programme on RTE 1. Spirit
Level got off to a promising start. Apart from the discussion (about
forgiveness), the show was more innovative and appealing with its musical
items - Nóirín Ní Riain sang the beautiful Jesus My All to Heaven Has
Gone, with her two sons, and we also saw her rehearsing for her recent
Celtic Joy album. In an interview with Anna Nolan she was positively
enthusiastic about the monastic life (she shares in the life of the monks
in Glenstal Abbey), about our roots in Celtic spirituality and about the
Holy Trinity (you don't hear enthusiasm for the Trinity too often in the
media!). A more surprising appearance was Luka Bloom (formerly Barry Moore)
who sang the catchy Don't Be Afraid of the Light that Shines Within
You (see video on left), a spiritual song in the broadest sense. The
show finished with Elikya, an African gospel group, from Limerick!
19/2/09
Recently I gave my TY students a homework to review
religious themes in a TV drama of their choice. One student did a review
of The Simpsons, but as I read his essay it began to sound familiar
- it was a piece I'd written for the blog on Faitharts! I reckon he had
copied and pasted the article from my website and handed it up to me as
homework! I asked where he got got it, and after looking a bit crestfallen
admitted he had copied off some website. I asked if he knew who wrote
it - "No", he said, "but it wasn't me". Actually it was me, I told him,
and explained that if he had looked more closely he would have spotted
my name on the page. Finally understanding, he broke into a broad grin
and said "isn't that ironic!".
11/2/09
Have been doing Baptism with my 6th Year students
and apart from covering the theology of it, have been using some video
clips. If anyone else has other arts resources for Baptism in mind I'd
love to hear about them, as I find it a tough subject with the seniors.
I started with a clip of the Baptism of Jesus. I used the scene from Jesus
of Nazareth with Michael York as John and Robert Powell as Jesus -
I find this the most effective clip. Other versions were just not as effective.
In Matthew, where Jesus is well played by Bruce Marchiano, John
the Baptist just looks silly I think, and Jesus comes out of the water
with a great splash and flourish which I liked, but I think my students
would only laugh. And as this version uses only the Bible text it's a
bit stiff, with characters saying nothing when you'd expect the to say
something! The Gospel of John suffers from similar problems, though I like
Henry Ian Cusick as Jesus. The film Jesus, with Brian Deacon, is also a bit stiff
for this scene (see over). Haven't seen any of The Greatest Story Ever
Told for quite a while, but the Baptism scene features some very tight
close-ups which have really gone out of fashion and look dated.
I also used a Baptism scene from the TV series Lost - and though
touching, it is problematic, and I felt the need to make some theological
clarifications! For example Mr Eko, who pretends to be, or believes himself
to be a priest, performs the Baptism on Claire and her son Aaron, and
refers to Jesus' sins being washed away! Earlier in the episode Charlie
had grabbed the baby and tried to do a secret Baptism, which at least
gave me a chance to discuss the inappropriateness of baptising those who
don't want it or whose parents don't seek it on a child's behalf.
I used a similar scene from The Simpsons, where Flanders tries
to baptise the Simpsons kids without their parents' permission (he has
an emergency Baptism kit at home). As the water is about to land on Bart
Homer leaps forward and takes the Baptism instead! He growls and grimaces
as if he was a demon after being exorcised, spouts some heavenly theology
and promptly reverts to normal. I think it's on the borderline of respect
(anyone think it's inappropriate?), but is good-humoured and can teach
many lessons about the sacrament in a way that gets the attention of teenage
boys!
There's another scene like that in the film Nacho Libre, where
a wrestling monk tries to baptise a fellow wrestler when he's not looking
- yes it's a wacky film! I also recall a Baptism scene in the film Oh
Brother Where Art Thou! , accompanied by the singing of Down in
the River to Pray. Yet the two who get baptised are dopey characters,
while suave George Clooney is cynical about the while thing, so I'm not
sure how the students would take this.
And speaking of Baptism music I might use that song even if I don't use
the film clip, though the best song I think is Carey Landry's You Have
Been Baptised in Christ - a good one to finish with as it captures
so many Baptism themes.